Circus Circus Mockup Challenge - FINALS - A vs I - poll voting threat (1 Viewer)

[wonderpuddle]

Congrats to the designers of A & I for making the finals! Please choose your favorite to take down the title.

A:

I:

 

[JeepologyOffroad]

Single spot pattern tourney sets ftw

 

[CraigT78]

Single spot pattern tourney sets ftw

Zzzzzzzzz

 

[JeepologyOffroad]

Zzzzzzzzz

Exactly. Just like tournaments themselves.

 

[CraigT78]

Exactly. Just like tournaments themselves.

I couldn't agree with you more.

 

[ImCrossland]

Why is this about to hurt so bad? #VoteForI

 

[Chippy McChiperson]

they’re both very nice mock-ups, but I had to go with A. I can’t say either flows better, since there is no spot progression in either (and doesn’t need to be, I usually prefer my tourney sets to have the same spot), so I went with which set to me has the better individual chips. I like the 25, 1k, 5k, and bounty better in A, and the 100 and 500 better in B (5 is a tossup). So for me, A wins 4.5 to 2.5.

 

[ImCrossland]

The 43mm bounty chip is the only thing I couldn’t do in a set. Other than that, I’d love playing with Tourney set A.

(But vote for I) haha

 

[ImCrossland]

 

[ImCrossland]

 

[WinterPoker]

For me, the 5, 100, 500, 5000, and bounty all look much better in the I set. Especially the 500! I think that purple chip would turn out amazing in person

 

[phaze12]

Had to vote for I.

Love the look of A but with those inlays and non traditional colors, I for see people checking the denoms and slowing the game down.
Now if the denom was a color that stood out, then A all day long.

 

[BSteck]

 

[BSteck]

Vote ‘A’ if only to tighten the vote totals so I can demand a recount tonight.

 

[Thisfiendis138]

Tough one. Really dig both!
Went A, uniqueness

 

[JeepologyOffroad]

A in stacks would be so gorgeous. Quarter pie tourney sets are tough to beat.

All those 3d14 are nice chips but I’d murder them all into a cash set where 3d14 fits right at home.

 

[ImCrossland]

A in stacks would be so gorgeous. Quarter pie tourney sets are tough to beat.

All those 3d14 are nice chips but I’d murder them all into a cash set where 3d14 fits right at home.

Versatility baby

 

[Ben8257]

Voted A, beautiful line up and love quarter pies. Those colors are awesome

 

[ImCrossland]

Voted A, beautiful line up and love quarter pies. Those colors are awesome

I will never recover from this. If I’ve lost Ben, then I’ve lost everything.

 

[Ben8257]

I will never recover from this. If I’ve lost Ben, then I’ve lost everything.

Is your line up the other one Tristan? I don't even know who designed each one! Lol

But I have always been obsessed with quarter pie chips! @H|Q Harlequin chips are amongst my favorite chips I have ever seen. BCC Riverboat V1s, @detroitdad Bourbon Basements. It's ok that we all like different stuff.

 

[ImCrossland]

Is your line up the other one Tristan? I don't even know who designed each one! Lol

But I have always been obsessed with quarter pie chips! @H|Q Harlequin chips are amongst my favorite chips I have ever seen. BCC Riverboat V1s, @detroitdad Bourbon Basements. It's ok that we all like different stuff.

Haha all in good fun, brother. A is an incredible mock-up. @BSteck Hell of a job on these!

 

[wonderpuddle]

Got a few hours left. Get those votes in.

 

[Don Clay]

Voted for A, all the way.

I'm still wondering how those would be made though.

And to be clear, I wouldn't mind being included in an Angel private buy.

 

[BSteck]

Haha all in good fun, brother. A is an incredible mock-up. @BSteck Hell of a job on these!

Back atcha! Yours is a great lineup too! (a close second in my book)

 

[ImCrossland]

Victory!

This was way more fun(stressful) than I ever thought it would be. First time being nominated for one of these design contests so thanks @wonderpuddle for putting this on!

I loved so many of the other designs, like @BSteck and @Chippy McChiperson that I was sure I was crushed when this thing first started. I refreshed the original voting thread non-stop on Day 1 just hoping I would make it to a respectable number and I couldn’t believe the #’s.

Thanks to everyone who voted for #TeamI

Let’s goooooooooooooo

 

[JeepologyOffroad]

Nicely done Triston. Can’t wait to murder those into dreamy Cali $1s

 

[ImCrossland]

Nicely done Triston. Can’t wait to murder those into dreamy Cali $1s

Thanks, brother!

When I originally saw the nomination, I was hoping it was for a circus cash set. Pulled the T5k directly from my Cali Cash $1 design I’d already messed around with.

The bounty chip was pulled from the cash set as well. Only difference was the base color is Blurple and it’s used as a $20. Looks much better than the white base IMO.

 

[ImCrossland]

 

[Don Clay]

Congratz for your victory, Triston!

 

[Natesroom]

A