Do you consider these chips mint? (3 Viewers)

mcguiles

3 of a Kind
Joined
Apr 25, 2018
Messages
614
Reaction score
636
Location
Denver, CO
I recently acquired two racks of murdered ES fracs. They were sold to me as mint condition and I did receive photos ahead of time. In the photos that I will attach shortly you can see these chips are stacked. I don’t know how it would be possible to not notice how wobbly and how warped some of the chips are in these two racks. Please see the attached video and let me know your thoughts

i’ve offered the chips back to the seller at a $400 loss and they have not responded to me…

 
here are the photos before the sale
 

Attachments

  • 93684BDD-5FC4-473B-A90A-68E6EB54CF74.png
    93684BDD-5FC4-473B-A90A-68E6EB54CF74.png
    297.2 KB · Views: 295
  • 1F3967CA-55E2-4514-96BE-828CEB8A3E2E.png
    1F3967CA-55E2-4514-96BE-828CEB8A3E2E.png
    345.8 KB · Views: 297
I recently acquired two racks of murdered ES fracs. They were sold to me as mint condition and I did receive photos ahead of time. In the photos that I will attach shortly you can see these chips are stacked. I don’t know how it would be possible to not notice how wobbly and how warped some of the chips are in these two racks. Please see the attached video and let me know your thoughts

i’ve offered the chips back to the seller at a $400 loss and they have not responded to me…

To my knowledge the term mint has nothing to do with stable or wobbly but with the unused surface of the chips.
 
You can flatten these chips by baking. Search the forum and you will find numerous threads ;-)
 
Chips are no longer "mint" once they are played with, their labels are removed (which was known), there is any damage (like a flea bite), or they have had any work done on them, including simply lightly oiling them. If the only issue is them being wobbly/warped, that can be easily fixed for less than taking a $400 hit. That could have also simply happened in transit due to something like heat.

Beyond that, it's hard to comment without knowing more or hearing the other side. I try to avoid the term mint unless there's really no other way to describe them.
 
Chips are no longer "mint" once they are played with, their labels are removed (which was known), there is any damage (like a flea bite), or they have had any work done on them, including simply lightly oiling them. If the only issue is them being wobbly/warped, that can be easily fixed for less than taking a $400 hit. That could have also simply happened in transit due to something like heat.

Beyond that, it's hard to comment without knowing more or hearing the other side. I try to avoid the term mint unless there's really no other way to describe them.
This.

I feel like the word "mint" gets thrown around far too liberally. Avoiding situations like this is one of the main reasons I try and avoid describing condition when I sell chips and just let potential buyers make their own judgment based on photos.
 
Last edited:
200 chips were sent in a small flat rate box with no protection between the chips or in the interior of the box. it was well packaged on the outside but 200 chips jammed into the box
correction:

small amount of bubble wrap on one end of the box
 
200 chips were sent in a small flat rate box with no protection between the chips or in the interior of the box. it was well packaged on the outside but 200 chips jammed into the box

I'm not sure how that's even physically possible, but what does the part I underlined mean? Was it sent in just that or was the SFRB inside of something, and if so, what?
 
I think it was wrapped in one padded envelope or maybe too I don’t remember exactly.
 
I know the video only shows one barrel but every single barrel is like this
 
This has been known to happen in transit sometimes if the chips get hot (like in the back of a delivery truck in the recent heat waves we've been having). Packing tightly into std cardboard boxes can help, but not always.
200 chips were sent in a small flat rate box with no protection between the chips or in the interior of the box. it was well packaged on the outside but 200 chips jammed into the box
This is fine for something like used roulettes or solids, that should never be done for $1k+ in near mint chips though.
 
the term "mint" is way, way overused (as is the redundant "dead mint").. It is used to convey that the chips are just like new...

In my opinion, warped chips are not mint. Just like sun bleached chips would be not mint.
 
I think it was wrapped in one padded envelope or maybe too I don’t remember exactly.
Specifics will matter, because there is a method of putting two warnekes inside a not fully sealed SFRB and taping it up, followed by putting that in a padded/bubble envelope, followed by putting that in another one. Example link. It is a good method assuming the padding/taping is done well.
 
Specifics will matter, because there is a method of putting two warnekes inside a not fully sealed SFRB and taping it up, followed by putting that in a padded/bubble envelope, followed by putting that in another one. Example link. It is a good method assuming the padding/taping is done well.
Yeah, I've had chips shipped to me without issue using that method. They were packed tight and more than enough padding.

The chips were not in chipboxes within the small box.
The chips were loose inside the box? If so, that's pretty bad. Did you snap a photo of that?
 
i did not
Yeah, I've had chips shipped to me without issue using that method. They were packed tight and more than enough padding.


The chips were loose inside the box? If so, that's pretty bad. Did you snap a photo of that?
 
Yeah, I've had chips shipped to me without issue using that method. They were packed tight and more than enough padding.


The chips were loose inside the box? If so, that's pretty bad. Did you snap a photo of that?
How loose could they be, if there were 200 of them in a SFRB?
 
As others have indicated, “mint” is basically just behind “dibs” in being the most overused and least useful term on PCF.

In your first photo, the first stack of chips, about 1/3 of the way down, I can’t tell if that’s a gap or a shadow.

The lack of communication is concerning as was the packing “method”, but this could just be a heat issue. Coms with the seller would help clear that up.

Good luck!
 
I don't know you and don't know the seller or the deal and accordingly don't have a horse in the race, but would recommend slowing things down a bit.

1) These chips aren't mint simply by being murdered.

2) Airing it out publicly, this should already have multiple days in PM without reply or a couple of back and forths with a seller unwilling to do anything - otherwise, you're going to look like the pain in the ass. Way too often these threads get created after 45 minutes without a reply.

3) Those are definitely wobbly, some heat/storage issues likely, and it is fixable as others mention; don't think it's a $400 issue, that's a little nuts.

4) Packing method went from no protection to small amount of bubble wrap on one end of the box to wrapped in a padded envelope within 4 minutes of posts. And then the chips not being in chipboxes. Not having a straight story doesn't help your case and seller probably isn't going to be inclined to be more helpful if your earliest posts were disingenuous.

Would recommend stopping replying to this thread and trying to work things out directly with the seller. If a few days pass and nothing, come on back here.
 
Mint has transformed into a BS term here on PCF for marketing purposes to extract the max amount from buyers.

It's laughable that these murdered chips were described as mint to you. The seller is either incredibly ignorant or blatantly misusing the term. But you were sent photos ahead of time so you should have known these were not mint chips.

However, spinners have nothing to do with the condition of a chip. For example, back in the day BCC has terrible QC. People would receive orders that were warped as hell - much worse than your video. But these were still mint chips direct from the factory.

What was likely the issue with BCC and perhaps your chips are the conditions they may have been subjected to in transit. BCC operated in Las Vegas so it's likely they sat in a mail truck and were subjected to some intense heat which may have caused the warping after manufacture.

If I were in your shoes I'd just try flattening them.
 
Angry Ben Book warning... it's been a while, Ye Bee Warned!! Lol

I have been fighting this fight since the begining of my time in this hobby. I recieved a barrel of chips described as "mint" and they were 5 times worse than that... some were flat out banana chips! I absolutely HATE that almost no one ever mentions the flatness of the chips.

I say this in all seriousness, over 70% of all clay chips that have ever come to my house have had some degree of warpage issue but almost never mentioned! I spend hours flattening chips then people say "well it should be mentioned that you have flattened the chips!" So that should be mentioned but not the fact that you are selling warped chips to begin with.

The forum defended the seller of that awful barrel that I purchased on eBay because it was a vendor here. I was told "that is just the way it is and accept it!"

Recently I saw a set sell that I had played and knew they were warped and no mention of them in the listing of being "Mint!"

Take 10 seconds, grab any clay barrel, sit it on a hardwood or granite counter top and tap the top edge, if they move AT ALL, I mean even in the slightest... you have warped chips in that barrel. The newer, the lighter and the brighter the chips are, the more prevalent it seems to be!

While typing this I picked up the 43mm Grand casino chips. The secondary 25k is supposed to be brand new... it's warped to sh*t
20220524_153233-jpg.916690

Change the order and hold them up to the light.. what do you know the sec $1k is warped
20220524_153449.jpg

It is almost impossible to show multiple gaps of light in a single picture from a barrel. Grab a chip set it on a flat surface and tap the top... most clay chips are warped even leaded THC, but typically less than these cheaper chips.

I recently bought a 944 chip set of FOC BCC, typically BCC doesn't have these issues but every single chip in the set was warped! It took me almost 2 months of flattening to get them close, every single day and absolutely no mention of the fact that some chips were difficult to fit 19 chips per barrel, yeah that warped!

I didn't get any level woth the face pictures but look at the height differences across this set. The chips are all near mint, no wear but look at the tops of the barrels, especially obvious from the $5s to the $25s... look at the shadows and height differences, they should all be the same.
20220119_161332.jpg

I did snap this lovely shot
20220123_140516.jpg

And BCCs are much more dense than Paulson. It takes multiple heating sessions for longer times to get them to move at all! It was terrible!! Are you telling me the seller had "no clue" these were warped. You could blow on them and they would wobble all over the place, literally made me sick and wanted to blow up on that guy, seri2 months to get them close flattening chips for 6 - 8 hours every damn day!

It's taboo to talk about so shhh!! You will get PM hate mail. This was bought from another vendor here
20201205_194411.jpg

For a premium price and again no mention of any warpage.

Got in a fight with a CCGT member on eBay, valued member runs some Colorado branch of the club. He said both sides shown which was a lie... same pic twice and wasn't even the same chip. Had all the proof, went to Spragg about it and nothing done. Asshole even tried to tell me it was worth more because warped chips are rare!
20210411_111827.jpg

Warped so bad the inlay was popping out!
20210411_015308.jpg

Not to mention the chip was dog Sh*t! Compared to the picture shown.
20210411_015509.jpg

Told me he didn't have time to take pictures of every chip... even though that is exactly how the listing read. Told me everyone does that, they use generic scans. He offered a refund if I sent the chip back. Why should I take the time to package, my money to ship, when you are being totally fraudulent. So what get my $10 back so you can force this on some other non knowing poor soul? Told him enjoy my $10 and kept the chip... still have it today!

Think AS NAGB are exempt?
20210201_173215.jpg

Absolutely not!

Don't worry folks.. in a couple days this will get pushed back under the rug until someone brings it up again.

It is mostly fixable if you know what you are doing and are careful. Most get inpatient and want faster ways and wind up squishing chips (makes an indentation around the ring of the chip)

But some of us have learned the art of fixing these poor souls. Before
20211202_201911.jpg

After (left two barrels)
20211207_200615.jpg

Btw with time they start warping again, same chips today about 5 months later
20220524_160223.jpg

The chips I flattened are on the left still and top 3 of the middle barrel. That took about 3 weeks to flatten 25 chips. If I did it again maybe they would stay a little flatter, this is an extreme example but shows well in pics. It can be done but extremely labor intensive and time consuming!

Keep up the fight of full transparency on chips. I absolutely think sharing the video and NOT calling out the seller shows a lot of class @mcguiles .. I would be pissed too! But know this happens all the time and is not discussed. 10 people will now likely send me a PM about flattening chips, it happens every time I talk about it. There is definitely not enough money to be made/damage risk to take that on for others. My oven would be running for hours every day!

BTW expect the same response from every single seller "they weren't like that when I had them... must have happened in shipping!" Ask me how I know

Edit** one more just for Poops and Giggles... how about brand spanking new out the box from Paulson RPCs
20220524_161415.jpg

Literally brand new 43mm IHCs . They ain't cheap either!
 

Attachments

  • 20220524_153233.jpg
    20220524_153233.jpg
    60.4 KB · Views: 671
Last edited:
I don't know you and don't know the seller or the deal and accordingly don't have a horse in the race, but would recommend slowing things down a bit.

1) These chips aren't mint simply by being murdered.

2) Airing it out publicly, this should already have multiple days in PM without reply or a couple of back and forths with a seller unwilling to do anything - otherwise, you're going to look like the pain in the ass. Way too often these threads get created after 45 minutes without a reply.

3) Those are definitely wobbly, some heat/storage issues likely, and it is fixable as others mention; don't think it's a $400 issue, that's a little nuts.

4) Packing method went from no protection to small amount of bubble wrap on one end of the box to wrapped in a padded envelope within 4 minutes of posts. And then the chips not being in chipboxes. Not having a straight story doesn't help your case and seller probably isn't going to be inclined to be more helpful if your earliest posts were disingenuous.

Would recommend stopping replying to this thread and trying to work things out directly with the seller. If a few days pass and nothing, come on back here.

seller thinks the chips were totally fine and shocked that I had any issues with them or the packaging. I explained I was going to air this out publicly and see what the opinion was by other people.

as I explained 200 chips packed into a small flat rate box with no packaging on the interior except for one small piece of bubble wrap on one end of said box. i’m concerned about the packaging on the interior of the box versus the exterior that is my concern.

sure i can flatten them, or put in work to correct them. but that’s not what i paid for. i paid for mint chips that wouldn’t need any work.
 
i’ve offered the chips back to the seller at a $400 loss and they have not responded to me…

seller thinks the chips were totally fine and shocked that I had any issues with them or the packaging.

So you have had some dialog with them? Or they haven't responded?

Not looking to get into it with you even though it probably seems like I am - just suggesting to be really clear with your communication when trying to air out a conflict. Your initial post made it seem like you had a completely unresponsive seller.
 
If the chips aren't in the unopened, original packaging from the manufacturer, they aren't mint. After passing through several owners and several repackaging and sales even less so.

Our hobby makes a mockery of the concept of "mint". So much so that the term loses all meaning. Buyers need to be acutely aware of what they are paying for and basically agree to take the chips as is.

The original poster is clearly on notice these chips aren't mint no matter what the seller said. The have been "murdered". Whatever processes were used to remove the inlay is going to damage the chip. What exactly was the expectation?

I have no idea if any fault has happened or who might be to blame. The seller spews meaningless garbage if he/she used the word mint. But the buyer is obviously on notice the chips can't be mint. I appreciate the buyer isn't happy. But I can't tell if the seller did anything misleading beyond making up the mint condition of the chip.

DrStrange
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account and join our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom