Not to beat a dead horse, but I agree with @Poker Zombie this isn't perfect!I have used the compression method for a year now on over 20,000 chips.
I do everything exactly the same as the OP other than I absolutely do wipe the entire chip after the drying period. I don't see how a quick wipe is pulling out the oil that has soaked into the clay.
Excess oil os going to then absorb into your cloth or felt along with dirt, skin particles (dust), any food that may not have been properly washed off. All of this is what we refer to as Hooker Juice, its nasty when you get used chips but can you imagine basically your entire playing surface absorbing hooker juice... yuck!!
There are 100 ways to skin a cat as they say, find what works for you! I prefer this method but do not leave your chips wet. After wiping them off they will still have that beautiful bright color and be properly sealed. It's even hard to imagine players didn't complain about oily hands after playing those chips!
Just my 2 cents on the subject!
Fellow Chipper Ben
**Disclaimer: I've only used this method to oil paulson chips**
Definitely agree @Ben8257 @BearMetal . I've only oiled after cleaning (and drying) my chips. I now tend to use as little oil as possible and apply using a piece of foam, which allows me to oil all sides. I only use enough to re-hydrate the chips though, and allow the coloring to pop again. As @allforcharity mentioned, light compression does have it's merits, and for me, some light pressure is needed to make sure that the oil hits the hat/cane and other recessed areas of the chip. I've tried moderate amounts of oil before (not even as much as the OP suggested), and found that the excess oil just sits on the surface. Even after laying out on drying racks for 24-48 hrs, excess oil that's not absorbed just pools on the chips. I need to wipe them down before racking them and even after that, some oil still seeps out over the next few days and sometimes a week or so (the heat also pulls the oils out a bit too). The times that i've used just enough oil to bring the coloring back, I've noticed that the chips dry much quicker (~24 or less hrs) and the oil doesn't seep out as much when they're racked up.