Alright, my code is running my model for the next day and I can't analyze it until its done with 55k iterations, SO you're all gonna get a frustration of mine.
Spoilers for the movies listed ahead but its been a decade, deal with it. I am fuzzy on the details but I really had the red string out back then, I'll see if my thesis still holds.
My stance:
The Dark Knight Rises and Skyfall are the same movie, they have an annoying number of parallels that I cannot unsee.
Introductions
Dark Knight Rises, 3rd movie in the Dark Knight trilogy. Focused around the events following Dark Knight, Batman comes back from being missing/retirement to fight the bad guy.
Skyfall, third movie in the Daniel Craig Bond-era. Following the events of the past two movies, Bond returns from being missing/dead to fight the bad guy.
Similarities:
- Both heroes return when they are needed, but are older, more tired versions of themselves that fail raw competency tests. Their reflexes have slowed, and people around them question whether they are still fit to fill the massive shoes the last few movies have prescribed. Bruce is injured and reclusive after Joker and Two-Face do a number on Gotham, and Bond is insecure after returning from his gunshot and fall. Both are insecure, and there's a vulnerability weighing on them while they undergo tests to see if they're still capable/worthy.
- Both are haunted by an external member from their past that has had the same training. Bond is against Silva, an ex-MI6 spy trained in the same way that Bond was, that's how he knows how to infiltrate MI6 after being purposefully captured. Batman is against Bane, a man trained by Ra's al Ghul who trained Bruce in the first movie. He was also purposefully captured to start the movie. Both movies feature this idea, of a stranger (to us but not to the organization) making their way back to hurt it from the inside, disfigured by their interactions with the real world, frustrated with the way the world is running.
- Both scheme for years and finally spring it, baiting the hero into their game while returning to the hero's home base. Both returns to their "homes" mark being in danger, unsafe; Bane is waiting in the batcave and Silva is chasing Bond to his childhood highlands home. Clearly nowhere is safe, the threat has to be dealt with. Silva attacks MI6 and the city, Bane attacks Wayne Enterprises and the city, both are targeted assaults on what we've seen as base in the previous movies.
- Endings show both Batman and Bond to be mortal but they are saved by some of the only friends they have as they're on the brink of death. In the previous movies, both have been shown to be near-super human with their gadgets and grit; this movie is different, they're still the lynchpins that hold it all together but lean heavily on the supporting cast. In both movies they enable their friends (Cops/Catwoman/M/Bill) to defend them, defeating Bane and wiping out most of Silva's army.
- The hero is responsible for the final save using the skills they are famous for but once doubted: Batman uses his jet to take the bomb out and save the city, Bond throws a knife across the church to kill Silva. This is not terribly similar, but they had to have the final word. Batman couldn't take out Bane and Bond would lose to Silva's bullet after blowing his house up, but they get by with a lil' help from their friends.
Contrasts and Mitigating Factors
- Ending message is very different. Bruce is retired on a beach after detonating the bomb over the ocean, but Bond is "ready to get back to work". Both were framed as old and ailing at the start, but now both seem stable.
- Although Bane and Silva are both formidable foes and they're both very intelligent, they're still significantly different. Both lead men into battle but Silva is a wiry assassin while Bane is a brick shithouse.
Conclusion
Eh, they're very similar, but it may just be a third installment thing because the more I look, the more I see this trend. It may have just seemed more pressing because I saw these within a month of each other. I need to rewatch at least Skyfall. All of this post was driven by Skyfall coming on my Spotify playlist.
The whole mortal/doubtful protagonist thing is big in third installments, not just these two, third movies are a way to lower past accomplishments while building more on backstories and character flaws. I probably have a lit nerd rolling their eyes at me somewhere because this is a common theme I'm just figuring out.
-----Rocky III, Clubber wins and he loses Mick, doubts himself and his training.
-----Return of the Jedi, not physical vulnerability but he's mentally tried, doubts himself and his lineage.
-----LOTR: Return of the King, Aragorn doubts whether he should be King and Frodo almost falls short.
-----Iron Man 3, suit and mind are failing Tony Stark and it almost costs the world. He doubts himself and his suit.
-----Capt America Civl War, doubts himself and his organization, haunted by Bucky from his past.
-----Matrix Revolutions, Neo is maimed and doubts himself, eventually accepts he's part of something bigger.
-----Thor: Ragnarok, Thor is stripped of his powers and becomes mortal-ized, being maimed and humbled.
Thanks for coming to my TedTalk, good to revisit this a decade later.