POLL- IT'S A POLL CLEAN or CLOVERS (2 Viewers)

[SeanGecko]

 

[arch3r]

Clovers. Seems to balance the outer right.

 

[detroitdad]

clean

 

[200 Motels]

I like the clovers but I feel the inlay still needs help. Thoughts on centering the denom and making the $ smaller and off center? Also the font is kinda meh and not sure how good the white outline on the denom would look irl.

That $5 chip is pretty killer imo.

 

[Coyote]

It's too fine a detail, but why not?
Clovers never hurt anyone

 

[SeanGecko]

I like the clovers but I feel the inlay still needs help. Thoughts on centering the denom and making the $ smaller and off center? Also the font is kinda meh and not sure how good the white outline on the denom would look irl.

That $5 chip is pretty killer imo.

 

[bsdunbar1]

I voted clean and at this point the votes are about even, it always comes down to - What do you as the owner want to look at??

 

[AnteAndy]

Clovers. Helps fill in a lot of that empty space on left and right sides that the circle enough cannot help.

Couldn't tell they were clovers at first unless I really zoomed in. But those symbols help balance the whole composition of the inlay more.

 

[FordPickup92]

Clovers. Seems to balance the outer right.

Agreed

 

[SeanGecko]

One of the reasons for the clover is to follow the theme with the PLAQUES made by SAL.

 

[Kensco]

I like the clovers. Maybe just make them bigger & break the line of the inner circle to do so.

Also, maybe center the denom on the dollars and reduce the size of the currency symbol. The fracs seem okay as is, but the off-center dollars seem awkward to my eye.

(Imagine these colors inverted)

 

[SeanGecko]

I like the clovers. Maybe just make them bigger & break the line of the inner circle to do so.

Also, maybe center the denom on the dollars and reduce the size of the currency symbol. The fracs seem okay as is, but the off-center dollars seem awkward to my eye.

(Imagine these colors inverted)

View attachment 390382

DUDE I was almost there! Where did you make this?

 

[Kensco]

Illustrator

 

[SeanGecko]

Illustrator

I like the first one. If I could make it look more like the set I have. Giving me thoughts now.

 

[Kensco]

I like the first one. If I could make it look more like the set I have. Giving me thoughts now.

If your weather is anything like ours this weekend, you've got plenty of time to work on it!

 

[SeanGecko]

I like the CLOVERS stem facing towards each other, makes a good circular feeling. I need the outer white line. THANKS for all the votes people. CHEER.
Special thank you to @Kensco

 

[FordPickup92]

I'm liking the second row adjustment

 

[detroitdad]

I still prefer the clean look

 

[allforcharity]

Clovers

 

[Jordan Downs]

Clovers

 

[AnteAndy]

I like the CLOVERS stem facing towards each other, makes a good circular feeling. I need the outer white line. THANKS for all the votes people. CHEER.
Special thank you to @Kensco

View attachment 390450View attachment 390451

liking the second row. Can definitely tell they're clovers.

Liking more the currency symbols more now that they're smaller than the numbers, plus the numbers having slightly different shapes. Thinner, bigger font of the names are a plus, as well.

The $5 five number is filled in under the top horizontal part of the number compared to the first.

Looking again, I kinda miss the top ring that's missing in row two that row one has. But shrinking up everything in the inlay would fix for adding it.

 

[Geremie]

Clovers....maybe color match the clover to the denom

 

[Rhodeman77]

I like the bigger clovers and the centered denomination a lot more. It’s getting there!

 

[SeanGecko]

Welp @Kensco created some new black and white art for me and has caused me a larger problem now. THANKS. Seriously I do appreciate the assistance.
Sooooooooo

 

[AnteAndy]

Welp @Kensco created some new black and white art for me and has caused me a larger problem now. THANKS. Seriously I do appreciate the assistance.
Sooooooooo

View attachment 391541

I'm starting to like the white inlay more, especially with the black $1 so it can stand out between each denomination and not blend in with the chip.

 

[200 Motels]

Not to give Kensco more work but a gradient background can do wonders for a chip inlay. I think the white looks like the inlays were printed on a xerox. Although the design looks better with the centered numbers.

 

[SeanGecko]

Clovers....maybe color match the clover to the denom

 

[AnteAndy]

View attachment 391566View attachment 391567

Oh. I actually like having the clover be a different color from the egdespots. Definitely help make them stand out more. Having the clovers be the same color as the denom when the rest of the inlay is white might blend the clovers and denoms together more, but This image here helps make the inlay stand out more for each denominated chip.

 

[Coyote]

Welp @Kensco created some new black and white art for me and has caused me a larger problem now. THANKS. Seriously I do appreciate the assistance.
Sooooooooo

View attachment 391541

Honestly, please adopt the first three chips in this line-up and keep your own 8A14 $5

 

[SeanGecko]

Honestly, please adopt the first three chips in this line-up and keep your own 8A14 $5

He made the labels I designed the chip. Glad you like them.