POLL: PCA Sec $100 vs. Aztar MO Sec $100 (1 Viewer)

[churlbut18]

The question has been raised...

Head to head... Which do you like better?

Vote now, comments are welcome...

PCA Secondary $100

Aztar MO Secondary $100

 

[BGinGA]

spots: Aztar (even though I'm a huge 818 fan)
inlay: Aztar
overall: PCA

PCA works much better in most mixed casino sets.

 

[churlbut18]

spots: Aztar (even though I'm a huge 818 fan)
inlay: Aztar
overall: PCA

PCA works much better in most mixed casino sets.

I like the PCA $25 / Aztar MO $100 combo better than Aztar MO $25 / PCA $100 (all Secondary)

 

[fish72s]

For me the question is which chips do I most regret selling

 

[Mac128k]

Aztar has an unfair advantage this time of year (for most of us) because of the fall colors

 

[kk405]

Aztar, only because I have an incomplete PCA set, am looking for the secondary hundos and hope the rest of you buy Aztars instead

 

[upNdown]

They're both awesome, how could you go wrong? I voted PCA, but I maybe should see the Aztar in person. Something about the brown spot on the black chip doesn't thrill me - not enough contrast. But it may look better in person.

 

[churlbut18]

They're both awesome, how could you go wrong? I voted PCA, but I maybe should see the Aztar in person. Something about the brown spot on the black chip doesn't thrill me - not enough contrast. But it may look better in person.

I thought it was more of a maroon than brown, but maybe not.

 

[Numerobis]

I was never a big fan of the Aztar (except the spotted tourney ) but i must say this 100 rocks

maybe pictures in stacks of both chips could help as well, if someone can post

 

[Rhodeman77]

I love the PCA set but I think the Aztar is a ever so slightly cooler chip.

Can't go wrong with either in a mixed set.

 

[72o]

Great poll! Tough poll!

Both chips are special and I love 818 spots but I ultimately voted for the Aztar because it uses the best shaped inlay shape (cog) and for the denom placement. Something just feels right when the denom is on the bottom...it just anchors the inlay there (center position also works though).

 

[flipupchipup]

 

[upNdown]

View attachment 128811

View attachment 128812

whew, I might have to change my vote

 

[liftapint]

If anybody has a mint barrel of either chip that they want to sell, I would love to add them to my "Barrels o' hudos" collection (which I'm just getting started).

 

[ovo]

AZ is the best

 

[TheBigTater]

In a vacuum without context (other chips in a set for comparison) I like the PCA 818.

 

[GIANTDustySquid]

Wow. Too close, can't vote

 

[Milo013]

PCA, and I have played with both. Never liked the brown on black in the Aztar chip.

 

[churlbut18]

@softchewy

 

[liftapint]

If anybody has a mint barrel of either chip that they want to sell, I would love to add them to my "Barrels o' hudos" collection (which I'm just getting started).

If anybody has a mint barrel of PCA and wants to trade for Aztar...let me know. I could use a barrel of PCA for my "Barrels o' hundos" collection