• This site contains affiliate links. If you choose to make a purchase after clicking a link, Poker Chip Forum may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for your support!

Not Mine Super Mario Bro Replica? (2 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.
KarateMaster72 said:
So I just commented on his Facebook page under the ad for these. I said
" dude You know you stole this super poker world artwork off of a member on poker chip forum not cool"
He needs to be banned from this site
Click to expand...
He hasn't posted since he asked how to get ahold of Tina. I doubt he cares at this point if he gets banned.

Tina making RHC chips is in bad taste, but I don't blame her. Someone (I think from another poker site) requested them, so she'll make what customers ask for. THIS, on the other had is much worse, because many of us have talked to her and asked her not to reproduce other's work. And I've seen it in writing where she said they wouldn't. Those of us who are buying a lot from her, like @justincarothers and @SeanGecko need to ask her about this. We have given them a SH!T TON of business. She needs to know that this is really wrong, and that it will impact whether we continue to use her for additional mountains of business!
 
TX_Golf_N_Poker said:
He hasn't posted since he asked how to get ahold of Tina. I doubt he cares at this point if he gets banned.

Tina making RHC chips is in bad taste, but I don't blame her. Someone (I think from another poker site) requested them, so she'll make what customers ask for. THIS, on the other had is much worse, because many of us have talked to her and asked her not to reproduce other's work. And I've seen it in writing where she said they wouldn't. Those of us who are buying a lot from her, like @justincarothers and @SeanGecko need to ask her about this. We have given them a SH!T TON of business. She needs to know that this is really wrong, and that it will impact whether we continue to use her for additional mountains of business!
Click to expand...
I’m not trying to re-rant old rants. But from her perspective, it’s okay to print anything. And we as a community have ordered countless copies of chip designs we don’t own. But now you want to tell her which designs are okay to copy? I just don’t think she’s going to get it and I certainly don’t expect her to care.
I’m in the hobby, so I understand the rationale that you’d never copy another chipper’s design. But even being in the hobby and appreciating the sentiment, I still think it’s pretty thick hypocrisy to copy a casino’s design on Monday but get upset about copying a chipper’s design on Tuesday. So I’m just saying, I hear you, but I don’t think you can hope to get anywhere with her.
 
TX_Golf_N_Poker said:
He hasn't posted since he asked how to get ahold of Tina. I doubt he cares at this point if he gets banned.

Tina making RHC chips is in bad taste, but I don't blame her. Someone (I think from another poker site) requested them, so she'll make what customers ask for. THIS, on the other had is much worse, because many of us have talked to her and asked her not to reproduce other's work. And I've seen it in writing where she said they wouldn't. Those of us who are buying a lot from her, like @justincarothers and @SeanGecko need to ask her about this. We have given them a SH!T TON of business. She needs to know that this is really wrong, and that it will impact whether we continue to use her for additional mountains of business!
Click to expand...
But as far as I know, Tina never printed the originals. BRPro produced the Mario line, right @rjdev7 ?
I was thinking the art was grabbed from either proofs or printed pieces and sent to Tina or some other Alibaba vendor.
 
Colquhoun said:
But as far as I know, Tina never printed the originals. BRPro produced the Mario line, right @rjdev7 ?
I was thinking the art was grabbed from either proofs or printed pieces and sent to Tina or some other Alibaba vendor.
Click to expand...
OK, if that's true then that's a big difference. I saw those when they came out, but was not involved, so I was thinking that they were originally done by Tina. If not, then she's just printing art that someone else sent her, and the ones who sent it to her are the ones who copied it, not her printing something that someone sent her and requested that she not reproduce without approval.

upNdown said:
I’m not trying to re-rant old rants. But from her perspective, it’s okay to print anything. And we as a community have ordered countless copies of chip designs we don’t own. But now you want to tell her which designs are okay to copy? I just don’t think she’s going to get it and I certainly don’t expect her to care.
I’m in the hobby, so I understand the rationale that you’d never copy another chipper’s design. But even being in the hobby and appreciating the sentiment, I still think it’s pretty thick hypocrisy to copy a casino’s design on Monday but get upset about copying a chipper’s design on Tuesday. So I’m just saying, I hear you, but I don’t think you can hope to get anywhere with her.
Click to expand...
I know you are anti-Tina and anti-cards mold, so you are probably not aware that several of us have had conversations with her about this matter. She has stated in the past that she would not reprint original art previously submitted to her without the creator's approval. But if as stated above, the originals weren't ever submitted to her in the first place, then she hasn't knowingly broken her commitment.
 
TX_Golf_N_Poker said:
OK, so we just give up? I think I said a lot more than stop or I'll say it again... :mad:
Click to expand...
I'm just saying that's effectively what Tina would hear. There will be no litigation so there's no threat. My comment was not aimed at anyone's post but at the situation. Unless there's a substantial boycot of Tina's that affects the bottom line the machines will keep on rolling. And honestly, how many consumers will care enough about the theft of rjdev7's design (which itself is kinda a theft, no?) to not order their Cards Mold BTP's or Sunset Beach?
 
PCF: Don't print my artwork, man! We won't work with you if you do that.

PCF: Ok, now where were we. Oh, right! So we'll take 20,000 Bellagio replicas, 12,500 WSOP replicas, 12,000 Horseshoe replicas, 50,000 RHC molds,...

I get it. This Mario thing is some bush league bullshit (seems to be a theme on here from a certain type of folk), and is a super sucky situation for rjdev, who has brought us some absolutely cool products. But we opened the can of worms. We wanted ours, and don't want others to have theirs. It doesn't work like that.
 
Last edited:
upNdown said:
I’m not trying to re-rant old rants. But from her perspective, it’s okay to print anything. And we as a community have ordered countless copies of chip designs we don’t own. But now you want to tell her which designs are okay to copy? I just don’t think she’s going to get it and I certainly don’t expect her to care.
I’m in the hobby, so I understand the rationale that you’d never copy another chipper’s design. But even being in the hobby and appreciating the sentiment, I still think it’s pretty thick hypocrisy to copy a casino’s design on Monday but get upset about copying a chipper’s design on Tuesday. So I’m just saying, I hear you, but I don’t think you can hope to get anywhere with her.
Click to expand...
Good thing. I've never bought copies of other chips then.
 
Venturalvn said:
PCF: Don't print my artwork, man! We won't work with you if you do that.

PCF: Ok, now where were we. Oh, right! So we'll take 20,000 Bellagio replicas, 12,500 WSOP replicas, 12,000 Horseshoe replicas, 50,000 RHC molds,...

I get it. This Mario thing is some bush league bullshit (seems to be a theme on here from a certain type of folk), and is a super sucky situation for rjdev, who has brought us some absolutely cool products. But we opened the can of worms. We wanted ours, and don't want others to have theirs. It doesn't work like that.
Click to expand...

Are you equating an active member to a casino brand?
 
doublebooyah85 said:
Rules for thee but not for me lol
Click to expand...

I get the concept but don’t agree that they are equal situations. One is a corporation litigating and protecting their brand. Good. They have the right to protect their brand. The other is a forum contributor having their work stolen and sold without their consent and they can’t litigate it like the bellagio can.
 
ngmcs8203 said:
I get the concept but don’t agree that they are equal situations. One is a corporation litigating and protecting their brand. Good. They have the right to protect their brand. The other is a forum contributor having their work stolen and sold without their consent and they can’t litigate it like the bellagio can.
Click to expand...
And why can’t he litigate it like Bellagio? It’s shitty what @JLApoker did but it’s still a bit hypercritical lol
 
ngmcs8203 said:
Remember all those music owners who tried suing MadTV? Remember how MadTV lost? No? Oh that’s right. Fair use in parody. Rjdev wasn’t just copying and pasting someone else’s work.
Click to expand...
1689999561386.gif
 
So let me see if I understand this correctly, we are complaining about someone stealing a design that was stolen from someone else’s IP and we are okay with lifting IP from casinos and other large companies because they have lots of money to protect their IP but it’s hard for chippers who stole the original IP to protect their copies
 
Bluegrass Poker said:
So let me see if I understand this correctly, we are complaining about someone stealing a design that was stolen from someone else’s IP and we are okay with lifting IP from casinos and other large companies because they have lots of money to protect their IP but it’s hard for chippers who stole the original IP to protect their copies
Click to expand...

Was the super Mario poker artwork created for this community original or lifted?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Sparkynutz
Wanted 1 up Mushroom chip
Replies
0
Views
107
Sparkynutz
Sparkynutz
iLogik
  • Locked
Giveaway Super Poker Bros
Replies
21
Views
1K
iLogik
iLogik
Yant0
Super mario poker chips
Replies
1
Views
684
spartan037
S
K
  • Locked
For Sale Super MarioBRPro Ceramics - Cash/Tourney Set
Replies
12
Views
1K
KiddyGamezDTR
K
Chris Manzoni
  • Locked
SOLD Super Mario BRPro Ceramics - Cash Game Set
Replies
5
Views
905
Chris Manzoni
Chris Manzoni
Back
Top Bottom