Thanks everybody! It was a super fun process and I am very happy with the end results!
I ended up finding the Stones Gambling Hall chips, both the Tavern and the Saloon, and really fell in love with the Saloon.
This is basically a recreation of their Saloon chips, but slightly different inlay and very different edge spots.
I decided that I loved this Saloon theme + logo better than my original mountain/beer designs.
I fooled around with the idea of adding small bottles/glasses/mugs to the designs for different denoms, but ultimately decided to keep it uniform. I am sure that a better designer could have come up with a fun and creative way to incorporate something like that, but I knew I'd love this simple design as well!
Thanks everybody for the feedback all throughout my design process! I'm sure I'll be adding onto this set to make a full 1000 chip set with many different cash and tournament options.