A lot better. Also, it cost less than $50. ($20 for foam, $20 for remnant1, <$10 for remnant2). And I can tinker with it if I decide I want to try something else. For instance, if I want the playing surface to give slightly more, I can add another piece of fabric or a $10 layer of foam from Joann's under it. (Tried that, felt it was too mushy.)
To me, what matters most is (A) can you pick up cards/chips easily, (B) do the cards move smoothly, (C) do I have to worry about spills, and (D) do I have to spend a half-hour setting up the table? This solution resolves all four questions swimmingly.
To me, what matters most is (A) can you pick up cards/chips easily, (B) do the cards move smoothly, (C) do I have to worry about spills, and (D) do I have to spend a half-hour setting up the table? This solution resolves all four questions swimmingly.