To my fellow model train nerds: any recommendations on a forum or starting point to learn about the various new digital control systems? I've been running Lionel trains for 35+ years on the older basic transformers. IE these things:
View attachment 962484
View attachment 962483
The kids are getting older and less interested, so I'd like to start getting some of my own stuff. We went to a train show today to look around, most of the engines I really liked were MTH with a ton of bells and whistles.
View attachment 962513
I think I'm at the point where I have to upgrade lol. I have zero knowledge about the new control systems, terms like DCS/TMMC/LEGACY/DCC are another language at this point. I don't mind taking the time to read on everything to learn, just looking for a good starting point. My current setup is all O scale and I have a bunch of Lionel fastrack & switches, mostly Lionel and K-Line engines and rolling stock - I'd prefer to keep as much of that as possible.
It’s been a while, so I’m probably not the best source. I have an O gauge Lionel and MTH set that I break out for Christmas. I ran into the issue with controllers as well. I can control go, stop, reverse with the old school Lionel for both (IRCC), but have to use the Lionel or MTH to get all the features to work (sound, smoke, decouple, etc) for each of them. I use banana plugs so I can swap the controllers easily.
I think Legacy means backward compatible for basic features (I think that’s a Lionel thing, but not sure). My MTH has DCS and it’s to control all the sounds, (protosounds etc) which are the whistle, bells, engine, dialogue, etc.
TMMC is Lionel’s version of DCS. I think Lionel might have a newer version out now.
Then I think there is something that allows you to control multiple engines on a single track, etc., which is way out of my league - lol.
From what I recall, MTH controllers won’t work for Lionel features and vice versa. They don’t play nice together in the sandbox - lol.
I ended up buying beef’ier x-formers because I have a decent size set up (I bought a lot of extra track to add on). I got the x-formers at train shows, and my local shop when I was in VA sold me the nicer MTH controller from a set he broke apart. My Lionel x-formers are pretty basic, my MTH has a remote control that I use - lol.
It’s been a good minute since I bought all this stuff, but seemed to recall MTH was offering a bit more for the $$. I run my MTH set way more then the Lionel, personally. But in all fairness, my MTH set is a way nicer set up and my Lionel is more entry level.