TLDR: Bought cabin and contents from uncle. Uncle has since started removing a bunch of items from cabin. It gets ugly.
This isn't a pleasant part of our journey, but it needs saying (unfortunately). I wanted to document and tell our entire journey (good and bad), and this is part of that. This involves a lot of emotion and stress. For background, my uncle is really my only remaining family member on my side of the family. He's older, cantankerous, stubborn, and very controlling (which if you've read this blog, you understand why he had a hard time letting go). That said, he is important to me. I have said that I didn't want any deal we made for the cabin and contents to get between us. That family is more important than stuff. We worked hard to ensure the deal we agreed upon was fair and acceptable to all parties. But there has been some bumps in the road...
There are a ton of details and nuances, but I'll share the cliffs: Part of our purchase agreement/contract was very clear, that from offer to closing (two months) my aunt and uncle were to remove from the main house and attached garages ALL personal items they wished to keep. The home was purchased "furnished", but they were also going to leave various tools and maintenance supplies necessary for the upkeep of the property. My uncle had 100% discretion as to what he wanted to leave us. We told them to take what they wanted (or simply move it to the detached garage). The contract was also very explicit that anything left in the house or attached garages transferred ownership at the time of closing. At every turn, we reminded my uncle to take what he wanted (and even offered to help move items for him), and he repeatedly said he had what he wanted, even telling us that after closing we should inventory the tools he left and add in what tools we felt we still needed.
After closing, we discovered a large amount of tools and supplies left at the cabin. Probably several thousand dollars worth. These have been very helpful in the property renovations. My uncle had three of every tool he wanted. He kept two sets at the cabin, and one back at his other main home. Prior to closing, he did take one of each tool back home, leaving practically one of everything at the cabin. We took his advice, we inventoried, we replaced certain items that were needing replacement, we added our own things, and they all got mixed together, reorganized, etc... It's our cabin now.
Buuut, in the 6-7 months since closing, my uncle has been back to the property a couple of times. Once by complete surprise, and the most recent by arrangement. In both cases he removed a bunch of items from the property, including around $1k in tools, and also household items like bags full of blurays, cleaning supplies, fuel pumps, spare tractor parts, new motor oil, a couple of battery tenders, and even a 6gal (brand new) container of diesel. The first time I blew it off, thinking it was just his snagging a few last minute things he absolutely forgot to get before closing, but this most recent time, he and 2 of his buddies spent 3 hours shopping around the property for stuff to take. I was beyond livid (and heartbroken). To make matters worse, my uncle says he simply believes he never agreed to include the tools in the sale, that he was just loaning them to us. That doesn't explain the other things he took...
I lost sleep over this for 3 straight nights. I was sick about it. My uncle had already confided in me that he seriously regrets selling the cabin, and it was presenting outwardly almost like a resentment.. Here we are, fixing up the place like he couldn't, and he has no control over it... His desire for control is the primary reason we insisted on a written contract that was very clear on ownership of the stuff. We didn't want any confusion or misunderstandings. Nor did we want him holding onto some weird attachment over the cabin or the stuff inside. However, that is exactly what has happened.
My aunt was furious with my uncle, and she has stated the contract and sale was very clear to her, and she has no idea what my uncle was thinking. He's so much of a control freak, he has repeatedly tried to shut my aunt out of all of the discussions, insisting that I not copy her on anything "because I'm causing her too much stress" and that "she doesn't want to be included"... This while my aunt is texting me to say none of that is true, and that she insists on being copied on everything.
So what did I do? My options were to just give in to my uncle and let him take anything he wanted. However, we already gave him that option (but the window closed on that 7 months ago), and it didn't prevent the current drama. And I don't think this is about stuff, it's about control. I was still seriously considering allowing my uncle to snag a bunch of the tools he left, but then when he started to try to control my aunt and shut her out, it became glaringly obvious that this was all about control, and had very little to do with stuff (after all, he has two of everything already). It also didn't help his cause when we started to discover a ton of the stuff he took wasn't just tools...
So, I put my foot down and told him he was out of luck. I'm sure this has permanently soured my relationship with him, but truth be told, I really don't like this side of him... I knew he was controlling, but this was over the top, and it totally reminded me of LOTR, where Bilbo gives up control of the ring, and meets up with Frodo later on... My uncle is like that, but didn't immediately revert back to kind frail Bilbo... He's gonna be bitter about this forever... My aunt has repeatedly told us we've done nothing wrong, and that it's my uncle that is out of line... but is still feels like a lose/lose situation to me.
I promise the next post will be back to happier subjects, like back breaking retaining wall builds...