Polochris
Flush
If money is no object, how about the Glenlivet 70?
They have a bottle in my poker pub (Whisky bar of the year a couple of times).
Only £900/dram. I like a double with cola (not Coke, I like my cola with a little bit of bite).
Otherwise, I'd second the old Highland Parks. The 18 yo was a favorite for a long time but is increasingly hard to come by (I think it has been commandeered to go into a high-end blend, so they're not bottling it anymore?).
If you like peat, the Lagavulin 16 is excellent. If you want to try something else peaty, check out the Ardbeg. I really enjoyed the Corryvreckan - it's like a peaty napalm bomb going off in your mouth.
I have no idea what is available in the US.
Where's @pltrgyst at? He usually has good whisky intel...
That loos amazing!
But did you say you would drink Glenlivet 70 with cola on the side or mixed in. I would think mixing any quality scotch would be a sin, but to each their own.