Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (31 Viewers)

Klobberer said:
Should I grab a few for JiJ?
Click to expand...

Completely up to you, I'm sure it'll be enjoyed if you grabbed one. I haven't grabbed anything specifically for the meetup yet. I should probably post a whiskey roll call in the meetup thread....

Billy Baroo said:
If you’re an ECBP fan, there’s not one thing wrong with A124. It’s great and the ones who balk at the age statement on that one are making a big mistake. If there wasn’t a limit on them, that shelf would be at least 2 bottles lighter after I left :cool
Click to expand...

^this^ not their best but certainly no slouch.
 
Last edited:
First time trying the 15 - definitely a nice step up from the 12, crazy tasty - cherries and dark chocolate :love:. I really need to grab a Port wood bottle to try.

20240428_205842.jpg
 
Billy Baroo said:
Donkey down!View attachment 1320092Got one more that I doubt will get opened for a while.
Click to expand...

I have one bottle of this GB left and I don't wanna open it because it was top tier. The second GB, I have 3 more bottles and don't like it quite as much so no trouble filling the void by opening another one of those instead. Actually drinking some of GB 2 now.

Time for GB #3?
 
Question for the experts.
Willet and the color of the top.....
I saw the black(ish) bottle with the purple top. I guess that is Bourbon.
Then I saw a bottle like the purple top I have pictured on page 909ish .. but it was 10yr and had a green top. I thought all of the "older" Willet Rye's had purple tops.

This place had the purple top for 399, the 10 year for 499. A tad pricey, but not terribly unreasonable from what I understand.
 
krafticus said:
Question for the experts.
Willet and the color of the top.....
I saw the black(ish) bottle with the purple top. I guess that is Bourbon.
Then I saw a bottle like the purple top I have pictured on page 909ish .. but it was 10yr and had a green top. I thought all of the "older" Willet Rye's had purple tops.

This place had the purple top for 399, the 10 year for 499. A tad pricey, but not terribly unreasonable from what I understand.
Click to expand...
Purple tops are Bourbon. Green are Rye.

I could be wrong on this but I believe all the older purple tops were sourced. Now they distill their own. The black bottle with the purple top is a wheat mash bill that is their own product.
 
krafticus said:
Question for the experts.
Willet and the color of the top.....
I saw the black(ish) bottle with the purple top. I guess that is Bourbon.
Then I saw a bottle like the purple top I have pictured on page 909ish .. but it was 10yr and had a green top. I thought all of the "older" Willet Rye's had purple tops.

This place had the purple top for 399, the 10 year for 499. A tad pricey, but not terribly unreasonable from what I understand.
Click to expand...


Most green tops are rye
Purple tops are bourbons
Some of the black tops are blends?
They also have wax tops which are $$$$$
 
Payback said:
I have one bottle of this GB left and I don't wanna open it because it was top tier. The second GB, I have 3 more bottles and don't like it quite as much so no trouble filling the void by opening another one of those instead. Actually drinking some of GB 2 now.

Time for GB #3?
Click to expand...
I’d love to do another pick! I’m still disappointed that I couldn’t make it to the 2nd one. I had a blast doing the first one. If I’m being 100% honest, I would rather do a rye pick instead but that’s just one rye loving donkey’s opinion :ROFL: :ROFLMAO:

I’m thinking rye might be a touch more difficult to get enough bottle commitments though.
 
Klobberer said:
Should I grab a few for JiJ?
Click to expand...
Check that, if you haven't already grabbed it, don't. I forgot I had found one on sale last week and grabbed it. Too busy for my own good lately. If you did no worries, I can never have enough of these lol.
 
Nothing special BUT…they’re finally distributing to NC! Mrs Baroo grabbed this for me while out in the western Carolina mountains over the weekend. She recognized the name and thought I’d like one! Might just have to keep her :cool
IMG_7258.jpeg
we should be seeing the bonded and single barrels in bourbon and rye and eventually the 8yr bourbon as well as the 6yr malted rye.
 
I saw two New Riff single barrel bourbons at one of my locals today - one was $50 and the other $70. The latter appeared to be a store pick, had the extra sticker like the donkey bottle with the pick store (9th floor something). Assuming that's the deal with these New Riffs - they distribute "generic" single barrels and then the particular store picks run a little more?

Both looked to be bottle a couple of years ago
 
IMG_3607.jpeg


Bought this for my game, mostly for the entertainment value of the name and label.

Pretty typical of Japanese whiskeys which I favor, but others might dislike for the same reasons I like them… Lighter color, not an overwhelming % of alcohol, very drinkable without my having to be too precious about it.

Set me back about $50. As you can see from the picture, the guys didn’t like it at all.
 
Last edited:
Taghkanic said:
View attachment 1321106

Bought this for my game, mostly for the entertainment value of the name and label.

Pretty typical of Japanese whiskeys which I favor, but others might dislike for the same reasons I like them… Lighter color, not an overwhelming % of alcohol, very drinkable without my having to be too previous about it.

Set me back about $50. As you can see from the picture, the guys didn’t like it at all.
Click to expand...


I’m had a bunch of mediocre Japanese whisky but all of them have made a good highball
 
Pinkdan said:
Well I guess now is as good a time as any to crack the Cal. Unfortunately I only have the 16, not the 15View attachment 1320751
Click to expand...
Cal 16 took it

It had a more enjoyable drinking experience. More astringency and drank above its proof in a good way. The SH was medicinal cherry cough syrup. Probably more balanced of the two but that note killed it for me

I’m being super nit-picky btw. The SH is a fantastic pour
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account and join our community. It's easy!

Register

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Similar threads

warma
Help: whisk(e)y tasting at poker night
2 3 4
Replies
93
Views
4K
warma
warma
Back
Top Bottom