I've seen the movie 3 times now and it became a topic of conversation at
@bergs' game this weekend. I think
@JoseRijo and I agreed that the fact that the movie lifts the majority of its plot from A New Hope (and some elements of Empire) causes its rating to go down when viewed in the context of the entire franchise, but that it was an absolute blast in theaters.
Speaking for myself, I put a significant amount of stock in first-watch enjoyability and this movie had it in spades. Just an absolute blast, particularly to see it on opening night with a bunch of Star Wars nerds in the audience. It's sort of like seeing a horror movie in a packed theater. It makes it all the more enjoyable. I guess some could say it gives the movie an unfair boost, but I disagree. I see movies like this to have a good time. If I want intellectually stimulating movies that will stick in my head to get mulled over for weeks, I'll look someplace else.
I'm surprised to see negative comments on the score. I'm also surprised that I see I didn't praise it earlier. I loved it and even more so by the third watch. Rey's Theme, one of the more subtle themes among the new material is my favorite:
Another very positive attribute of the movie is that it sets up all future movies extremely well. The fact that we weren't spoonfed the details of this or that - despite the fact that it is the source of much whining - is exactly why the movie sets up future films well. They will be able to mine a lot of the material that has been left unclear at this point.
George Lucas' recent quotes also came up in conversation at the game this weekend. Evidently he said to some reporter that Disney wanted to "retro" movies and that those are exactly the movies he was trying to avoid making. I actually think this is a good point, but has little weight since this guy, when given all the license and means to do whatever he wanted turned out some absolute garbage.
If someone said that The Force Awakens is weak because it doesn't build onto the previously established cannon, I can't really argue. But what it does is give the franchise a kickstart of interest and optimism and a new baseline from which to build hopefully interesting and compelling stories. Since the prequels pretty much deflated all hope of Star Wars ever being great again, that's a huge plus.
So if Lucas wanted to jump in and use some of the creative genius that he showed in the first two films and in his other film
THX 1138, I'd be all for it. But since he torpedoed his opportunity to do so, I'm glad to see new talent being brought in. I view JJ Abrams' role here as something of a showrunner position: he's established the feel of the films to come and will now step back and let other talent branch out. In that way, he did his job perfectly and set the stage for what could be some great movies.
Rian Johnson is working on the next movie and anyone who saw Looper should be glad. Gareth Edwards is doing Rogue One, the movie set between episodes three and four. These have much more promise now that we've seen that the decision makers actually have a grasp on how to make a great Star Wars movie. I suspect that - Disney being Disney - we'll all be thoroughly sick of Star Wars in the next six to ten years, but at least in the meantime we'll have some fun stuff to watch.