In the hickok45 beneli video, he had three feed issues by the 18 minute mark. No, thanks, especially if you are planning this for home defense and aren’t going to practice with it much.
I am not a fan of the safety on mossbergs but If you must choose between beneli and the mossberg then I’d go with the mossberg.
Too bad you didn’t have a good experience with the Remington 870. That’s the gold standard for work-a-day pump shotguns. This one is great:
https://www.remington.com/shotguns/tactical/model-870-express-tactical
The shotgun, with an 8 shot (bird shot) load is a great choice for home defense, especially from a penetration standpoint. Almost every other round (even a .22) will cut through multiple layers of drywall presenting a hazard to your loved ones in other rooms or neighbors. There’s a good video on this out there somewhere.
Also, I feel compelled to suggest that you get more than some practice in whatever platform you eventually purchase. If you’re wanting to use this in an actual critical situation then you want to know where everything is on the weapon and how it all works like the back of your hand. In a home invasion situation, it is likely that your stress level will be off the charts and your body will be hyped up on adrenaline. Your fine motor skills will suffer so that isn’t the time to be trying to remind yourself how stuff works. Get some proficiency with it, and then go regularly to keep that proficiency. It’s inconvenient, so most people don’t do it, but it’s essential.
Sorry for the soapbox there, just trying to encourage a good purchase and course of action.