Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (78 Viewers)

[Billy Baroo]

Special card capper making its debut tonight!

thanks@detroitdad

 

[joeyshin]

Happy Fryeday. @Josh Kifer is visiting. And he’s bougie. So I had to pull out the big gun.

View attachment 933578

No one got the joke that it cost me a handjob for that purple top. Lol

 

[Irish]

TGIF, finally got home after a long week on the road, 4 finger pour to finish off a tasty meetup bottle courtesy of my brotha @Ben8257

 

[Billy Baroo]

I knew this one was good!

 

[Jonesey07]

So it’s a smoke wagon night?

 

[Billy Baroo]

So it’s a smoke wagon night?

View attachment 933621

It is at my cash game tonight!!

 

[Big Jilm]

I recall making an old fashioned with a $500 bottle of Whistle Pig Boss Hog VIII once, lol. FOR SCIENCE!

Since I'm a crazy ass mofo fo-sho, here ya go: The Seagrass Old Fashioned bro bros...

3oz Seagrass
1/4oz Demarara
1 splash of Angostura
2 Fabbri Amarena cherries
It was chilled in the freezer....no ice, no melt!

 

[JustDave]

Slug of Calumet 16. Solid.

 

[gopherblue]

Fryeday.

 

[Big Jilm]

Shall I blind these tonight?

 

[wolfpack]

Whiskey Madness head to heads

C9 v C8

C9 - nose: minty, sweet, fruity
pallet: gum drops, oak, tastes good but not much of a finish, i think this is a low proof rye. would love to try this in cask strength

C8 - proof on the nose, dark chocolate
pallet: brown sugar, woody finish, good mouth feel, medium easy finish, seems to have some age.

Winner: C8

D10 v D9

D10 - Nose: vanilla, caramel
pallet; oaky, spice on middle, medium finish, goes down easy, tastes aged.

D9: nose: earthy, cinnamon
pallet: peanut, citrus on finish, medium finish, bright bitter finish, tastes younger.

These 2 felt about the same proof, maybe both BiB

Winner: D10

D8 v D7

D8 - Nose: proof, vanilla, caramel, heavenly I could nose this all day
Pallet: cinnamon, oaky, caramel, great mouth feel, long finish

D7 - Nose: Grainy, some citrus
Pallet: little bit of spice on backend, easy drinker, no burn but no finish. Low proof.

Winner by 1 punch knockout D8

 

[Big Jilm]

Whiskey Madness head to heads

C9 v C8

C9 - nose: minty, sweet, fruity
pallet: gum drops, oak, tastes good but not much of a finish, i think this is a low proof rye. would love to try this in cask strength

C8 - proof on the nose, dark chocolate
pallet: brown sugar, woody finish, good mouth feel, medium easy finish, seems to have some age.

Winner: C8

D10 v D9

D10 - Nose: vanilla, caramel
pallet; oaky, spice on middle, medium finish, goes down easy, tastes aged.

D9: nose: earthy, cinnamon
pallet: peanut, citrus on finish, medium finish, bright bitter finish, tastes younger.

These 2 felt about the same proof, maybe both BiB

Winner: D10

D8 v D7

D8 - Nose: proof, vanilla, caramel, heavenly I could nose this all day
Pallet: cinnamon, oaky, caramel, great mouth feel, long finish

D7 - Nose: Grainy, some citrus
Pallet: little bit of spice on backend, easy drinker, no burn but no finish. Low proof.

Winner by 1 punch knockout D8

DAMNIT I WISH I KNEW WHAT THEY WERE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[wolfpack]

DAMNIT I WISH I KNEW WHAT THEY WERE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Hell me to!

so far A1 and D8 have crushed the rest

 

[Big Jilm]

Ok here we go. Left to right, 1, 2, 3. Wife arranged them for me

 

[gopherblue]

Ok here we go. Left to right, 1, 2, 3. Wife arranged them for me

View attachment 933681

Oooh! Oooh! I know what Number Two is!!!

 

[joeyshin]

Ok here we go. Left to right, 1, 2, 3. Wife arranged them for me

View attachment 933681

I can tell by the color

P15, OWA, pmp

 

[wolfpack]

my predction

Pappy
poor mans pappy
OWA

 

[Pinkdan]

Oooh! Oooh! I know what Number Two is!!!

 

[wolfpack]

2 and 3 look the same to me

 

[gopherblue]

Shhhh…don’t tell Jilm, but it’s a bourbon…but not just any bourbon…a wheated bourbon.

 

[FDLmold]

Hell me to!

so far A1 and D8 have crushed the rest

I predict A1 is Ten High. D8 is Captain Morgan spicy that sneaked into the competition.

 

[wolfpack]

I predict A1 is Ten High. D8 is Captain Morgan spicy that sneaked into the competition.

god i wish. would save me a ton of money in the long run if that is all I had to buy.

 

[FDLmold]

god i wish. would save me a ton of money in the long run if that is all I had to buy.

Preach on brother. If I had it to do over again, I'd buy some MM 101, WT Rare Breed, some ECBP, some Alberta CS Rye, maybe some Seagrass, and be done.

 

[FDLmold]

Oh, and Redwood Empire. That shit is the bomb for $40.

 

[Big Jilm]

Ok, no notes because they were sooo similar. Wife said I nailed it initially, before I second guessed myself. Mixed up last and 2nd place after 20 strong minutes of being correct, lol

Last place: 1. Poor Mans Pappy
2nd place 3: Weller 107
1st place: Pappy 15

 

[joeyshin]

Oh, and Redwood Empire. That shit is the bomb for $40.

Have you tried any of the willett distillate? Old Kirk, Hirsch 6y, barrell bourbon dueling barrells, purple tops?

I was like you until someone ruined me

 

[joeyshin]

Ok, no notes because they were sooo similar. Wife said I nailed it initially, before I second guessed myself. Mixed up last and 2nd place after 20 strong minutes of being correct, lol

Last place: 1. Poor Mans Pappy
2nd place 3: Weller 107
1st place: Pappy 15

So adding w12 to OWA makes it worse. Noted

 

[FDLmold]

Have you tried any of the willett distillate? Old Kirk, Hirsch 6y, barrell bourbon dueling barrells, purple tops?

I was like you until someone ruined me

I don't recall ever seeing a bottle of any of these anywhere. I'm sure there are plenty of whiskies that would ruin what I consider good.

 

[joeyshin]

I don't recall ever seeing a bottle of any of these anywhere. I'm sure there are plenty of whiskies that would ruin what I consider good.

Let me send you some samples. Lol

 

[Big Jilm]

Wife ranked:

Pappy
PMP
107