For Finest Kentucky Oak? Or single barrels?
-
This site contains affiliate links. If you choose to make a purchase after clicking a link, Poker Chip Forum may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for your support!
Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (88 Viewers)
- Thread starter jbutler
- Start date
Billy Baroo
Full House
Billy Baroo
Full House
Ok…one more
Def tempted now. Heard that some of their older 21s are really 25s
Billy Baroo
Full House
I really need better secondary components, but this is still a pretty good cocktail!
Whiskey madness
C1 v C3
C1 - Cinnamon, spice, cherry
cinnamon, caramel, pepper, medium finish
c3 - earth, plum
oak, earthy, medium finish
winner: C1
C5 - mint, grass, red fruit
sweet berry, mint, pepper on finish, tasty, short finish mellow with no burn
c6- caramel, proof, grass
dill, brown sugar, pepper on finish, medium finish
these were both pretty good, but C5 just has a better taste
winner: C5
C1 v C3
C1 - Cinnamon, spice, cherry
cinnamon, caramel, pepper, medium finish
c3 - earth, plum
oak, earthy, medium finish
winner: C1
C5 - mint, grass, red fruit
sweet berry, mint, pepper on finish, tasty, short finish mellow with no burn
c6- caramel, proof, grass
dill, brown sugar, pepper on finish, medium finish
these were both pretty good, but C5 just has a better taste
winner: C5
Billy Baroo
Full House
Man down! This was fantastic!
Billy Baroo
Full House
Indyscammer
Flush
This is just such a solid pour.
Absolute best value for Bourbon. So good. And a Noe selected bottle. Yummy.
Damn. Nose is ok, initial palate is ok, then it turns into brand new star wars figurine. Particularly, Han Solo with his Hoth gear. Some used tire notes as well....
Batch C920 is a VERY good batch. My 2nd favorite. So glad that I have a few bottles in reserve. 
Billy Baroo
Full House
That’s a new one to me.anyone ever tried this?
For people that know the Phoenix area, nice play on words. 2 guys from Scottsdale that commissioned a Scotch. Easy drink, nice flavor.
Billy Baroo
Full House
Might have got a little heavy handed, but it was gonna be finished tonight regardless!
Not whisky, but something I was searching for for a long time for a friend finally turned up.
oh wow very nice! Hendricks is one of my few non-whiskey guilty pleasures. Let us know what you think of it
it was some limited edition thing from like last year or something? these guys I use in the UK found it and I ended up getting it shipped to me from Slovenia of all places. I gave it 25% that I just got a box with a brick in it and 25% that it was going to be an empty bottle. Turned out successful. I'll report back once I get a chance to sample it with him.oh wow very nice! Hendricks is one of my few non-whiskey guilty pleasures. Let us know what you think of it
Whiskey madness
D1 v D3
D1 - earthy, proof, spice
pepper, oak, mint, long finish, good mouth feel
D3- dark chocolate, strawberry
earth, oak, caramel, short finish
Winner: D1
D5 v D8
D5- Caramel, proof, red fruit
caramel, vanilla, pepper, oak, long finish
D8- best nose through the competition, vanila, brown sugar, cherry, proof
vanilla, oak, spice, cherry on finish, long finish, oily mouth feel
this has been the closest of the competition its like a 5 outof 5 and a 4.99 out of 5.
winner by a faction: D8
I present your elite 8
D1 v D3
D1 - earthy, proof, spice
pepper, oak, mint, long finish, good mouth feel
D3- dark chocolate, strawberry
earth, oak, caramel, short finish
Winner: D1
D5 v D8
D5- Caramel, proof, red fruit
caramel, vanilla, pepper, oak, long finish
D8- best nose through the competition, vanila, brown sugar, cherry, proof
vanilla, oak, spice, cherry on finish, long finish, oily mouth feel
this has been the closest of the competition its like a 5 outof 5 and a 4.99 out of 5.
winner by a faction: D8
I present your elite 8
It’s still VERY good. Probably not $250 good. I don’t have it in me to make an old fashioned with it. Hahahahaha. Maybe another night.
Last edited:
Curios about this one. I'll have to pick one up next time I'm in TX. MGP correct?
I like everything Blue Note has put out, that being said, I liked crossroads the least. But its still good
I'll just pick one of each then!
Create an account or login to comment
You must be a member in order to leave a comment
Create account
Create an account and join our community. It's easy!
Log in
Already have an account? Log in here.
