Billy Baroo
Full House
I just recently killed one of those. I thought it was very tasty. There’s 3 different barrels of that floating around here so I might have to try out another one, you know, for science
Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (55 Viewers)
- Thread starter jbutler
- Start date
I’m a big Makers fan… and F*ck, had to buy it. I know I overpaid, but I bet I’ll not see it anywhere …. Or I’ll see it everywhere now that I picked it up…
Billy Baroo
Full House
After a long, blistering hot day of work it’s important to stay hydrated
Current collection: 114 bottles.
Current collection with more than a sample/neck pour missing: 50 ish
Unopened bottles: 63
I’m going to try to finish some of the opened bottles before getting more. Some opened ones I can’t get right now, so I’ll savor them…
Current collection with more than a sample/neck pour missing: 50 ish
Unopened bottles: 63
I’m going to try to finish some of the opened bottles before getting more. Some opened ones I can’t get right now, so I’ll savor them…
Billy Baroo
Full House
Let me know how that works for you. Less than a month ago I was sitting on about 50 bottles with about half of them opened. I told myself that I’d thin the herd a little before I buy any more…I’m now pushing about 70 bottles
#facepalm
Klobberer
Full House
You definitely headed down the rabbit hole...
Klobberer
Full House
I went from 50ish bottles to 200+ during Covid and never looked back...all open except for backups. Two open GTS for crying out loud, what's wrong with me!?
BruceWayne
Flush
BruceWayne
Flush
After a long, blistering hot day of work it’s important to stay hydrated
I will tend to back off bourbon if it's cooking outside. That's more captain and coke or Tito's weather hahaha
That being said, some of my favorite summer sippers are typically John J Bowman, anything Russell's or something 4 Roses
Forty4
Full House
Yeah something similar for me but a lot unopened. Like Krafty I’m trying to get through open bottles. I had to start stashing the new bottles at other locations.
Klobberer
Full House
Summer for me means a 40 oz Sailor Jerry and Diet Coke for my beach cocktail and Summer whiskeys until I pass out...
Billy Baroo
Full House
Love me some Sailor Jerry, but I prefer mine with pineapple juice and a splash of fresh lime juice. That’s my beach cocktail!
Last edited:
Klobberer
Full House
Used to be Diet Coke Lime, but they discontinued it...
Krafticus unicorn found. $170 before tax…. Hell yeah!!!
Last edited:
Billy Baroo
Full House
Damn you if you were one who “encouraged” me to explore Irish whiskey
Billy Baroo
Full House
Very jealous. This is one of a very few unicorns that if I ever see it at around retail, I will break my $100 rule. If I'm not mistaken, isn't $170 under retail for this bottle?
Warming up.
Jack Daniels Bonded Rye
Nose: Spicy herbal notes mixed with candied fruit - apple, pear and a hint of raspberry. Warm oak, vanilla and banana creep up in the background as it sits.
Palate: Dried fruit, oak and almost a mint up front, quickly drying out and moving to the rye and pepper spice, just a hair astringent at times. Very subtle hints of the typical Jack brown sugar, banana and vanilla form a base that lingers as the rye dries out. A couple drops of water really amplifies the fruit and sweetness ands helps tame any bitter notes, very highly recommended!
Finish: Medium intensity on the finish that lingers for a while, more of the vanilla/banana base notes come out as it finishes, all complimented by spicy rye notes that tingle the tongue.
Moving forward, I will always have a bottle of this on hand. Crazy great value. It was laughable that the JD bonded snagged the top spot on Whiskey Advocate's list in 2022 (the Triple Mash they released that year was better than the Bonded....) but this followup offering is really very good.
Jack Daniels Bonded Rye
Nose: Spicy herbal notes mixed with candied fruit - apple, pear and a hint of raspberry. Warm oak, vanilla and banana creep up in the background as it sits.
Palate: Dried fruit, oak and almost a mint up front, quickly drying out and moving to the rye and pepper spice, just a hair astringent at times. Very subtle hints of the typical Jack brown sugar, banana and vanilla form a base that lingers as the rye dries out. A couple drops of water really amplifies the fruit and sweetness ands helps tame any bitter notes, very highly recommended!
Finish: Medium intensity on the finish that lingers for a while, more of the vanilla/banana base notes come out as it finishes, all complimented by spicy rye notes that tingle the tongue.
Moving forward, I will always have a bottle of this on hand. Crazy great value. It was laughable that the JD bonded snagged the top spot on Whiskey Advocate's list in 2022 (the Triple Mash they released that year was better than the Bonded....) but this followup offering is really very good.
gopherblue
Straight Flush
Same same. I started with a shelf in one of the kitchen pantry cupboards. Then two shelves. Now I’ve taken over three whole cupboards in the pantry. And a limited amount of the overflow is in my home office, but most of the deep collection (e.g., 2-4 backup bottles of MWND from Act 7-Act 11 and many many others) are hidden in the guest bedroom closet. If my wife ever decides to clean that closet I’m a dead man.
gopherblue
Straight Flush
Excellent price. Well done!
gopherblue
Straight Flush
I have an extra backup, I think, that I’d be willing to part with, if you want to trade…I’d be looking for $150 in value.
Last edited:
Billy Baroo
Full House
Starting with a nice 95/5 MGP single barrel
Billy Baroo
Full House
Billy Baroo
Full House
Billy Baroo
Full House
Second taste of this one.....
(I'm glad I grabbed 2 bottles of this considering this one is half gone lol)
Old Overholt Cask Strength 10 Year
Nose: Cherry vanilla coke, with just a hint of rye and musty oak. Not overpowering at all.
Palate: Rye, cherry, dr pepper, vanilla and mollases up front, which quickly pivots to dry oak and light barrel char, a musty barrel. Very nice combo of spice and a deep sweetness.
Finish: the rye and oak barrel notes come through the most on the finish. Tingly but never outright spicy, the age becomes more prevalent as it finishes.
(I'm glad I grabbed 2 bottles of this considering this one is half gone lol)
Old Overholt Cask Strength 10 Year
Nose: Cherry vanilla coke, with just a hint of rye and musty oak. Not overpowering at all.
Palate: Rye, cherry, dr pepper, vanilla and mollases up front, which quickly pivots to dry oak and light barrel char, a musty barrel. Very nice combo of spice and a deep sweetness.
Finish: the rye and oak barrel notes come through the most on the finish. Tingly but never outright spicy, the age becomes more prevalent as it finishes.
Create an account or login to comment
You must be a member in order to leave a comment
Create account
Create an account and join our community. It's easy!
Log in
Already have an account? Log in here.
