Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (56 Viewers)

[gopherblue]

Yeah, super smooth. Often an entry level Bourbon, so wasn't sure how you'd like it given that you kind of dove headfirst into the Staggs and Handys

Grab a bottle of Henry McKenna for your collection as well while its still cheap

LOL, yeah, I went right for the good stuff.

Which of these next? McKenna at $60, OF 1920 at $60 or Noah's Mill at $45?

 

[ssanel54]

LOL, yeah, I went right for the good stuff.

Which of these next? McKenna at $60, OF 1920 at $60 or Noah's Mill at $45?

There is not a wrong answer, but of those three, I think McKenna is the closest to hitting allocated status, and wouldn’t be surprised to see it continue to go up in price.

Again, it used to be $35, then I think it won some award a year ago and flew off the shelves. Now it’s back in stock, but at a higher price and trending upward.

All of my experience is in MA, so could be very different in NY or elsewhere

 

[Klobberer]

LOL, yeah, I went right for the good stuff.

Which of these next? McKenna at $60, OF 1920 at $60 or Noah's Mill at $45?

$45 for Noah's Mill is a bargain. It's $55 retail in DE.

 

[Saoliver]

LOL, yeah, I went right for the good stuff.

Which of these next? McKenna at $60, OF 1920 at $60 or Noah's Mill at $45?

All of them. They are all great and so different. Noah's Mill goes for $60-$85 around here. It is a cinnamon bomb.

 

[ChaosRock]

LOL, yeah, I went right for the good stuff.

Which of these next? McKenna at $60, OF 1920 at $60 or Noah's Mill at $45?

For me, 1920 >>>> McKenna > Noah’s Mill. But that’s to my taste. I’d drink all three obviously as they are all good.

The McKenna is the one a bit harder to find although not that difficult. The other two should be plentiful.

The McKenna is a single barrel with high variance in quality btw.

 

[Pinkdan]

LOL, yeah, I went right for the good stuff.

Which of these next? McKenna at $60, OF 1920 at $60 or Noah's Mill at $45?

OF 1920 for sure IMO

 

[Indyscammer]

This seems appropriate in this thread.

 

[Saoliver]

View attachment 619208
This seems appropriate in this thread.

But the ice!

 

[Indyscammer]

But the ice!

Too much for sure. Sometimes 1 is ok.

 

[Godzilla28]

Just a dessert bourbon and a big bottle for the bunker since I heard Eagle Rare getting well rare.

 

[Saoliver]

Just a dessert bourbon and a big bottle for the bunker since I heard Eagle Rare getting well rare.

View attachment 619431

Huh...plenty of Eagle Rare in 3 stores that I know of. Maybe it’s all up here. I guess that I should add to the 6 bottles that I have.

 

[JeepologyOffroad]

Herman is such a secret chip tease in the whiskey thread

 

[Godzilla28]

Herman is such a secret chip tease in the whiskey thread

We'll, if you like that one, here's dessert.

 

[saleen121212]

I need a basement. Let's see the collections!

 

[Jonesey07]

I need a basement. Let's see the collections!

Just seeing those GTS bottles tilts me a little bit.

It's not you, it's the jealousy in me.

 

[Pinkdan]

Just seeing those GTS bottles tilts me a little bit.

It's not you, it's the jealousy in me.

 

[Regularjohn]

I need a basement. Let's see the collections!

love this set up. where did you get that shelf?

 

[Regularjohn]

also where did you get those separators?

 

[chrismurda]

It seems there is an overall general consensus to which are PCFs favorite whiskey/bourbons (Weller, stagg, four roses, old forester, etc)

may I request a general list of these whiskeys/bourbons with what a reasonable retail price would be as I’ve seen fluctuating prices from store to store? It would surly help when standing in the isle or liquor store debating on whether it’s +/- EV.

 

[Forty4]

They said it was FedEx ground on receipt. But I never got a shipping notice or tracking#. I still haven't heard from them, but I missed a signature required 21+ package from UPS today that shipped just 10 miles from Mora's. That is obviously it, just need my wife to answer the damn door tomorrow so I CAN HAVE MY PRECIOUS!

View attachment 617283View attachment 617287

Have you tried it yet? Had to grab a bottle today when I saw it. Came here to check if you did find it or if you needed the other bottle they had.

 

[saleen121212]

also where did you get those separators?

The dividers were from Amazon, they can be configured in many ways and are perfect for glasses/sample bottles. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08951NBKV/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o04_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

The shelves were custom built 20 years ago and I snagged them on FB Market place for $500, the lady showed me the receipt where she paid 5k to have them made 20 years ago and they still look brand new.

 

[Saoliver]

$316 with our ridiculous tax. I just couldn’t do it. But I am getting an Eagle Rare store pick that I am excited about.

 

[FDLmold]

For those who have tried it,
Bardstown Discovery #2
$107 out the door
Yea or nay?

 

[saleen121212]

For those who have tried it,
Bardstown Discovery #2
$107 out the door
Yea or nay?

Yes for sure. Retail is 120 or 130 and all of them are great

 

[Irish]

Friday treat ECBP. Getting into the whole clear ice thing now too lol, its pretty crazy how easy it is.

 

[chutracheese]

What's the clear ice thing?

 

[Irish]

There are a bunch of youtube videos, here's one (this one reminds me of @Ben8257 lol).

 

[Big Jilm]

Have you tried it yet? Had to grab a bottle today when I saw it. Came here to check if you did find it or if you needed the other bottle they had.

Thanks man, I scored one though

 

[JeepologyOffroad]

 

[Big Jilm]

EXTRA spicy on the nose, but such a great pour. Plus the cork ALWAYS POPS!! Great bottle and cork