Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (74 Viewers)

So...as evident from my (several) posts above, I had the afternoon free and decided to set out to find myself another bottle of Stagg Jr.

It didn't go well. Don't get me wrong--it was a hell of a way to spend a free afternoon with no obligations to the family...a crystalline, balmy 22 F day.

I went to (at least) 16 (I lost count) liquor stores, and put 160 miles on the odometer. I found, quite possibly, the most amazing small-town liquor store I've ever seen--they had EVERYTHING. And there was a reason for it--the most reasonably priced bourbon was 140% of usual retail in my area. We're talking GTS, Handy and other BTACs at $700 and up, Van Winkles from ORVW at $700 to the 23 at like $3600, and Weller SR at $140. Stagg Jr. at a (relative) bargain price of $165, but alas, no stock. :banghead:

Another store had ETL at $300, ORVW at $1200(!) and GTS at $450..."we always treat our customers well and price below what wine-searcher.com shows as far as pricing." :wtf::rolleyes: Well...to be fair, they were $2 below local retail on OF 1920. Still, a hard pass.

It was very much an Easter egg hunt--half the fun was plotting the itinerary and the other half was the anticipation when walking up to a new store and not knowing what lay within.

One store was promising--fairly reasonable prices, and even a price sheet posted on a case regarding their allocated bourbons, but Stagg Jr. was still $100, and out of stock. In passing, as with everywhere else, I asked the clerk if they had anything that wasn't out on the shelf. I asked about BTACs, including George T Stagg, but the clerk said no. Then she said "but stop back in a couple hours when the owner is here--I know she has a few things that she keeps for herself, but might sell." But I wasn't even halfway into my itinerary, and I wasn't passing back that way. So I took their card and said I'd call later.

Went to a great store that @bentax1978 recommended (that's where that $25,000 bottle of Pappy resides), and while they had a great selection at good prices, they didn't have what I was hunting. Still no Stagg Jr.

With three more stores left to visit, I pulled out the business card from that place I visited earlier, and called the number. The clerk had no idea (or recollection) who I was or why I was calling, but she handed the phone off to the owner. I introduced myself and told her I was in earlier in the day and the clerk had suggested I ask her if she had any allocated bottles available. She put me on hold, then came back and said, yes, she had one of the bottles I mentioned. I asked the price and she said she didn't know--she'd have to check the computer up front. After a few minutes on hold, and playing a game of over/under with myself on the insane price she'd quote, she came back on the line and told me.

I said "I'll take it. I'm about 40 minutes away, but I'll be there."

So, it was a good day after all--I didn't find what I was originally looking for, but so be it. The price? Well, let's just say it was a snap call. And I drove like hell to get there.

image0(3).jpeg
 
So...as evident from my (several) posts above, I had the afternoon free and decided to set out to find myself another bottle of Stagg Jr.

It didn't go well. Don't get me wrong--it was a hell of a way to spend a free afternoon with no obligations to the family...a crystalline, balmy 22 F day.

I went to (at least) 16 (I lost count) liquor stores, and put 160 miles on the odometer. I found, quite possibly, the most amazing small-town liquor store I've ever seen--they had EVERYTHING. And there was a reason for it--the most reasonably priced bourbon was 140% of usual retail in my area. We're talking GTS, Handy and other BTACs at $700 and up, Van Winkles from ORVW at $700 to the 23 at like $3600, and Weller SR at $140. Stagg Jr. at a (relative) bargain price of $165, but alas, no stock. :banghead:

Another store had ETL at $300, ORVW at $1200(!) and GTS at $450..."we always treat our customers well and price below what wine-searcher.com shows as far as pricing." :wtf::rolleyes: Well...to be fair, they were $2 below local retail on OF 1920. Still, a hard pass.

It was very much an Easter egg hunt--half the fun was plotting the itinerary and the other half was the anticipation when walking up to a new store and not knowing what lay within.

One store was promising--fairly reasonable prices, and even a price sheet posted on a case regarding their allocated bourbons, but Stagg Jr. was still $100, and out of stock. In passing, as with everywhere else, I asked the clerk if they had anything that wasn't out on the shelf. I asked about BTACs, including George T Stagg, but the clerk said no. Then she said "but stop back in a couple hours when the owner is here--I know she has a few things that she keeps for herself, but might sell." But I wasn't even halfway into my itinerary, and I wasn't passing back that way. So I took their card and said I'd call later.

Went to a great store that @bentax1978 recommended (that's where that $25,000 bottle of Pappy resides), and while they had a great selection at good prices, they didn't have what I was hunting. Still no Stagg Jr.

With three more stores left to visit, I pulled out the business card from that place I visited earlier, and called the number. The clerk had no idea (or recollection) who I was or why I was calling, but she handed the phone off to the owner. I introduced myself and told her I was in earlier in the day and the clerk had suggested I ask her if she had any allocated bottles available. She put me on hold, then came back and said, yes, she had one of the bottles I mentioned. I asked the price and she said she didn't know--she'd have to check the computer up front. After a few minutes on hold, and playing a game of over/under with myself on the insane price she'd quote, she came back on the line and told me.

I said "I'll take it. I'm about 40 minutes away, but I'll be there."

So, it was a good day after all--I didn't find what I was originally looking for, but so be it. The price? Well, let's just say it was a snap call. And I drove like hell to get there.

I admire your tenacity, but not your NY prices. You sir, have what it takes to win!
 
Was in Meijer tonight getting food to take back to school for my son (goes back to Pitt tomorrow). I'm checking out their really decent bourbon section ( realizing I need to look here more) when this lady walks up and says "were you looking for Eagle Rare" with a bottle of it in her hand. Since I was I said yes but was going to let her have it (she had another in her cart too). She said it's ok she is the liquor manager here . I met a new friend and paid $32 for the Eagle.
 
After 200+ store runs in central/north NJ over the last few weekends, I’m confident in saying that, if you’re visiting the area - probably wouldnt be a good use of time to hunt here if you’re looking to find reasonably priced allocated bottles :ROFL: :ROFLMAO:. There are a few stores that have/had stagg jr at $80 or less, so I’ll keep checking as the year goes on. ECBPs are still on some shelves and avg. around $70/$75 - $100 being top end. But similar to @gopherblue ‘s experience, the stores that are stock full of rare/premium bottles are all priced at the higher end secondary market prices. I’ve been striking out at most places, but i ran into some Eagle rare at $28/bottle that i couldnt pass up today - so i’ll consider that a small win lol.
I did run into some of these guys which i havent seen too often
88871EE2-5299-4609-9E37-3CB27AEF7C41.jpeg


Didnt scoop one, but I might consider it if he works with me on the price.
I did pull out a bottle i forgot i had. Nothing special but it has to be at least 7 years old by now - still tastes just fine to me! :ROFL: :ROFLMAO:
Couldnt find much info, but it’s from Batch No. 14-15
0D2AD292-7903-440D-B051-7AF5EA4C54E9.jpeg
 
Haven't had the Russell's yet so I cracked that one open tonight. Not sure what I think of this yet, every sip was a little different. Will have to revisit.

View attachment 617209

2nd, 3rd, 4th & 5th samplings of this Russell's single barrel during a 3+ hour game of Risk this evening were all very good. Lots of different flavor hints going on for a $50 bottle, definitely will be adding this to the rotation. Wrecked shop in Risk too lol ;)
 
2nd, 3rd, 4th & 5th samplings of this Russell's single barrel during a 3+ hour game of Risk this evening were all very good. Lots of different flavor hints going on for a $50 bottle, definitely will be adding this to the rotation. Wrecked shop in Risk too lol ;)
Ever try catan?
 
No, did a quick google search, looks interesting. We could use a new game, maybe I'll try to pick this up. Thanks!
I'm a fan of risk, but once i picked up catan after a friend's suggestion, that's all we play (*played). It's fun with a couple of people but best with 3-6 (including the expansion pack) imo
 
No, did a quick google search, looks interesting. We could use a new game, maybe I'll try to pick this up. Thanks!
If you like Risk, definitely check out Catan, and also look at a game called Scythe for something a bit more meaty/balanced.
 
After 200+ store runs in central/north NJ over the last few weekends, I’m confident in saying that, if you’re visiting the area - probably wouldnt be a good use of time to hunt here if you’re looking to find reasonably priced allocated bottles :ROFL: :ROFLMAO:. There are a few stores that have/had stagg jr at $80 or less, so I’ll keep checking as the year goes on. ECBPs are still on some shelves and avg. around $70/$75 - $100 being top end. But similar to @gopherblue ‘s experience, the stores that are stock full of rare/premium bottles are all priced at the higher end secondary market prices. I’ve been striking out at most places, but i ran into some Eagle rare at $28/bottle that i couldnt pass up today - so i’ll consider that a small win lol.
I did run into some of these guys which i havent seen too often
View attachment 620962

Didnt scoop one, but I might consider it if he works with me on the price.
I did pull out a bottle i forgot i had. Nothing special but it has to be at least 7 years old by now - still tastes just fine to me! :ROFL: :ROFLMAO:
Couldnt find much info, but it’s from Batch No. 14-15
View attachment 620968
How much for the Cigar Blend?
 
On my second run through, I give Scott's the better ranking. It is more balanced, more floral on the nose and has a more enjoyable palate. Mine brings the heat, has some nice cinnamon notes, but ultimately falls short on balanced flavor.

20210124_132231.jpg
 
I missed that post. Why do we think that? Just because of supply/demand? Damnt, 65 is about my max that I'm willing to spend on a bottle.
I'm hoping it's just speculation :dead: , because even though there are some places that sell the C920/B520 at $60-65 here, they're usually priced a little above that already ($70-$75) with some at $100/bottle
 
I'm hoping it's just speculation :dead: , because even though there are some places that sell the C920/B520 at $60-65 here, they're usually priced a little above that already ($70-$75) with some at $100/bottle
I'd still pay 75 for them. It's a 12 year barrel proof. Compared to similar stuff on the market its the best value in bourbon by far.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account and join our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom