They are both good but different. I prefer Noah’s.
-
This site contains affiliate links. If you choose to make a purchase after clicking a link, Poker Chip Forum may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for your support!
Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (84 Viewers)
- Thread starter jbutler
- Start date
Not disappointing. But I prefer Noah's. Rowan's is certainly worth a go
I can’t help myself
Wtf?!!? Nothing like Noah’s Mill. No cinnamon
Nose: Sooooo fruity. I don’t know how Minnick got dirt. He must have got a bad barrell. This smells delicious!! This is my 69.05%
Palate: I get cinnamon on the palate, but not overwhelming like the Noah’s mill. I get stone fruits, vanilla, and something else that’s tasty. I don’t have a great palate but this is freakin good!!
Finish: long, slight burn with lots of pepper. The kind of finish I really like.
If anyone else got this same barrell give me your tasting notes. I don’t have a great nose or palate but I just drink what I like. Someone with a better palate let me know what you taste so I can look for it. Im loving this and I think Minnick is wrong
Man this palate is almost as fruity as seagrass. Less apricot-y but so fruity. The cinnamon has taken a backseat after second and third tasting. I’m really digging this
Did you get one of these hirsch? In my opinion, it’s blowing Noah’s mill out the water. I almost don’t want to drink the Noah’s mill after this hirsch. But I’m not big on cinnamon
Mine is KY-044, same as @gopherblue.
How’s yours? Let’s trade samples if I don’t already have one of your barrels
No sir, I am indeed Hirschless!
Unopened. Won’t open until after St Paddy’s.
Sorry for the interruption....lol, I have been working on this post for 20min due to the heavy traffic, trying not to interrupt.
Had a Blantons first, now comparing an ETL. I like both of these over hyped Buffalo Trace difficult to find bourbons, but I certainly do not love them. I have to give the nod to Blantons as the better pour.
CARRY ON!
Had a Blantons first, now comparing an ETL. I like both of these over hyped Buffalo Trace difficult to find bourbons, but I certainly do not love them. I have to give the nod to Blantons as the better pour.
CARRY ON!
So I revisited my etl recently and I think the nose and palate is lacking compared to so many other bottles I’ve had recently, I have yet to find anything close to the mouthfeel and oily-ness of ETL which I really loved.
Now I can’t stop hiccuping like a cartoon drunk. Lol
We may all have the same KY-044 bottles if we all ordered from love scotch around the same time
; mine is 139.4p from there@joeyshin i have that KY-010 138.1p and it's pretty on point with what you mentioned - definitely no dirt and comparing it side by side with the WFE 6+yr purple top, imo the general flavor profile matches up pretty well too
Awesome. Mine is so freaking delicious. I’m putting it ahead of seagrass which I was the main hype man for. I’m afraid I’ll finish this bottle this month and I’m only drinking on weekends. LolWe may all have the same KY-044 bottles if we all ordered from love scotch around the same time
@joeyshin i have that KY-010 138.1p and it's pretty on point with what you mentioned - definitely no dirt and comparing it side by side with the WFE 6+yr purple top, imo the general flavor profile matches up pretty well too
So I found this review online and while it’s not the same barrell as mine, these tasting notes are spot on what I get.
https://www.amongstthewhiskey.com/p...ch-single-barrel-bourbon-head-to-head-reviews
I cracked it and tried it. I think it’s good for $40. I doubt it’s Willett.
“Trending towards some more earthy tones now, I'm getting topsoil, sawdust and something like a thick comforter.”
So dirt, like Fred. Hahahaha.
That’s a very promising review. Hoping my bottle is just as good.
FDLmold
Royal Flush
Jealous a little bit of that one. I gotta take photos of my open bottles and try to trade samples for some sweet samples.
gopherblue
Straight Flush
It’s MGP.
SOLD AMERICAN. LOL. I have 8 within reach....should be able to snag one before kick off tomorrow.
Low Roller night with the fam.
FDLmold
Royal Flush
Organized and made electronic my "you're new here, this is the available bourbon" shelf. Still deciding if I will have one secret list or two beyond this "public" list.
Please remind me which website that is.
FDLmold
Royal Flush
It's called me grabbing images from the internet and clumsily resizing them and adding them to a paint file.Please remind me which website that is.
Create an account or login to comment
You must be a member in order to leave a comment
Create account
Create an account and join our community. It's easy!
Log in
Already have an account? Log in here.
