Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (55 Viewers)

[RocAFella1]

Is the er17 as good as wlw? When I first tried wlw I was blown away. It was beyond anything I had tried since then and it was on another level. There was nothing I tried that was even close to it. Since then I’ve had a few pours of stuff that I might put in the same circle but still nothing as good as wlw. I need to know if er17 is as good or better.

Historically no but I haven’t had the recent iterations of either.

 

[gopherblue]

Is the er17 as good as wlw? When I first tried wlw I was blown away. It was beyond anything I had tried since then and it was on another level. There was nothing I tried that was even close to it. Since then I’ve had a few pours of stuff that I might put in the same circle but still nothing as good as wlw. I need to know if er17 is as good or better.

Different beast. WLW is barrel proof, and ER17 is 101 proof. Very different flavor profiles, but both excellent. ER17 seems to be the rarer of the two, and definitely easier to drink. Does it merit the insane secondary premium? I don’t think any of them do, but it is what it is.

 

[joeyshin]

Different beast. WLW is barrel proof, and ER17 is 101 proof. Very different flavor profiles, but both excellent. ER17 seems to be the rarer of the two, and definitely easier to drink. Does it merit the insane secondary premium? I don’t think any of them do, but it is what it is.

But how was that willett. I’m a willet whore. Its profile is so unique and unlike any other bourbons. I have 4 yr, 6yr, 8 yr. I would love some of the more aged and especially a silver top. But I’m dreaming.

 

[RocAFella1]

But how was that willett. I’m a willet whore. Its profile is so unique and unlike any other bourbons. I have 4 yr, 6yr, 8 yr. I would love some of the more aged and especially a silver top. But I’m dreaming.

You mean like this?

 

[joeyshin]

You mean like this?
View attachment 1255208

Yes!

 

[DZPoker]

First time I’ve ever come across it in a store. $69.99+tax = me very happy!!!

 

[Saoliver]

Not drinking. Still buying.

 

[Pinkdan]

First time I’ve ever come across it in a store. $69.99+tax = me very happy!!!

View attachment 1255260

Killer deal!!!!

 

[Pinkdan]

Not drinking. Still buying.

View attachment 1255332

 

[DZPoker]

Killer deal!!!!

And many many thanks for the sample of it you sent me…I never thought I’d own a bottle!

 

[joepro]

First time I’ve ever come across it in a store. $69.99+tax = me very happy!!!

View attachment 1255260

It’s also a beautiful bottle. It’s amazing what JD has been doing the last several years.

 

[krafticus]

33 runners tonight. Pre-gaming

 

[Saoliver]

33 runners tonight. Pre-gaming

View attachment 1255358

I’m yet to open my Barrell Vantage or Dovetail. I should do that.

 

[krafticus]

I’m yet to open my Barrell Vantage or Dovetail. I should do that.

I really like this one. You can tell because it’s almost half empty. Most of my bottles are only a pour or 2 short

 

[Billy Baroo]

Not drinking. Still buying.

View attachment 1255332

That Remus single barrel is great! If you haven’t had that particular 51/39/10 mashbill yet, you’ll be pleasantly surprised

I immediately went back for a backup the day after I cracked mine.

 

[Saoliver]

That Remus single barrel is great! If you haven’t had that particular 51/39/10 mashbill yet, you’ll be pleasantly surprised

I immediately went back for a backup the day after I cracked mine.

I’m most excited for the Old Overholt 10yr cask strength.

 

[Billy Baroo]

 

[Billy Baroo]

 

[joeyshin]

I’m feeling generous. Another giveaway?

 

[Pinkdan]

I’m feeling generous. Another giveaway?

 

[joeyshin]

I will send a bottle to the first person to guess my ultimate holy grail bourbon bottle. (Specifically bourbon so you don’t have to worry about Japanese whisky’s)

 

[warma]

I will send a bottle to the first person to guess my ultimate holy grail whisky bottle.

A bottle of your grail to someone who guesses it?

 

[joeyshin]

A bottle of your grail to someone who guesses it?

I wish I had a bottle of it

 

[Billy Baroo]

I will send a bottle to the first person to guess my ultimate holy grail whisky bottle.

Yamazaki 25

 

[joeyshin]

Yamazaki 25

I will let you guess again since I just changed it to bourbon instead of whisky. But yes I would love a yama25

 

[Payback]

I will send a bottle to the first person to guess my ultimate holy grail bourbon bottle. (Specifically bourbon so you don’t have to worry about Japanese whisky’s)

Willet Family Estate Single Barrel

 

[Pinkdan]

I will send a bottle to the first person to guess my ultimate holy grail bourbon bottle. (Specifically bourbon so you don’t have to worry about Japanese whisky’s)

King of Kentucky?

 

[DZPoker]

I will send a bottle to the first person to guess my ultimate holy grail bourbon bottle. (Specifically bourbon so you don’t have to worry about Japanese whisky’s)

 

[Hot Nuts]

joeyshin said:
I will send a bottle to the first person to guess my ultimate holy grail bourbon bottle. (Specifically bourbon so you don’t have to worry about Japanese whisky’s)

 

[Billy Baroo]

I will send a bottle to the first person to guess my ultimate holy grail bourbon bottle. (Specifically bourbon so you don’t have to worry about Japanese whisky’s)

Eagle Rare 25