Official PCF Whisk(e)y Thread (62 Viewers)

WE DID IT!!!!!!

0DF202BF-55AA-4948-8F1B-8F91F6168DDC.jpeg
 
so many things going on right now, no time for pics. First 2 pours tonight are:

Smoke Wagon -- the "normal one", lol
Murray Hill Club

Might go one more, any suggestions? That EC Toasted might be calling me again tonight....
 
Going with Sam Houston 15. @Saoliver because, well, you know why. Also, I haven't watched this video yet. Hope it is Oregon's (OR-1) and I hope it melts my face off my fucking head. Ok?

 
ok, as you could have seen from my pic, I have poured a few of these. It has gotten better with each pour. Matts assessment, doesn't quite match mine on the palate and the finish but the nose is spot on. They are different batches. I say this (OR-1) is very similar, early in the bottle to Calumet 15, but distinguishes itself quickly after some air. It is DAMN GOOD. I will have to do a heads up battle against Calumet 15 to be sure, but I am pretty sure this is better. I agree it isn't HOF, but I'm very happy I have like 6 bottles, LOL
 
Cracked open a new bottle tonight:

20211104_203211.jpg


Its been a while since Ive had a Four Roses offering, enjoying this a lot. Really nice nose - lots of vanilla with a touch of oak and sweet fruits (grape??). Similar notes follow through on the palate with some subtle dark undertones and peppery spice. Super smooth for 100+ proof. Finishes more peppery with some more oak and leather as it sits.
 
Any C921 tasters out there yet? I am interested in Matt's opinion AFTER several weeks have cleared the cracking. Not an auto-buy for me.....yet!
 
btw, I have been throwing that "HOF" around a lot lately. May I clarify?

My current HOF Confirmed:

George T Stagg 2020
Kentucky Owl Last Rye #4
Parkers Heritage Heavy Char (14?)
Alberta Premium Cask Strength Rye
Barrell Seagrass

Very Close:

MWND

Hopefuls/unopened in my collection...for the HOF

Eagle Rare 17 Year
Pappy 15
 
Last edited:
btw, I have been throwing that "HOF" around a lot lately. May I clarify?

My current HOF Confirmed:

George T Stagg 2020
Kentucky Owl Last Rye #4
Parkers Heritage Heavy Char (14?)
Alberta Premium Cask Strength Rye
Barrell Seagrass

Very Close:

MWND

Hopefuls/unopened in my collection...for the HOF

Eagle Rare 17 Year
Pappy 15
You need to run your GTS 20 against the 18 that I gave you. :)
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account and join our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom