Fellas… appreciate all the comments and advice. I’m so sorry I went MIA I didn’t think the post would continue to get traction and people so interested in the update
The long awaited update: I called the player the next day and talked about it. The box was over $200. I expressed my confusion on how we counted it out on the table and then told him to count it before he leaves but he just kind of trusted the count. With the game being relatively new and him being a new player there we came to the agreement that $250 would be fair. I agreed because $50 in the red was no big deal in my eyes to at least come to a resolution and since the box was over somehow anyway. I attribute any mistakes that night to exhaustion and lack of attention to both parties.
Since then I’ve had my games every single week and have not been over or under since.
I hope I made some of you happy with my return and won’t leave you guys hanging again lmao